osmandapp / OsmAnd

OsmAnd
https://osmand.net
Other
4.6k stars 1.01k forks source link

Display hazard nodes #16810

Open troelsarvin opened 1 year ago

troelsarvin commented 1 year ago

🚀 feature request

Description

I've tagged a rather dangerous place in Turkey, using the using the "hazard" tag. When tagging, I asked for advise in the mailing list on how to do it, and the current tagging is evidently the correct way to tag things.

Unfortunately, OsmAnd doesn't display the hazard, see attached screenshot below. OsmAnd does, however, display the other tag I added, displaying an icon for ruins. sshot_osmand_no_hazard_indication

End result is that my efforts may now be luring people to the area, bringing themselves in harms way, because they may fall down the hole which isn't being warned about. I'm uneasy about that.

Suggested solution

I suggest OsmAnd display a hazard-icon for nodes which has the "hazard" tag. And maybe even sound an alert, sort of like OsmAnd does when you are (for example) approaching a speed bump.

Zirochkabila commented 1 year ago

TagInfo hazard=hole TagInfo hazard OSM

@troelsarvin The offer is interesting But I'm not sure we'll implement it because of the small number of tags We need to clarify with @vshcherb and @xmd5a2

scaidermern commented 1 year ago

It is not strictly necessary to support hazard=hole in OsmAnd. It would be sufficient to add a generic rendering for any unknown hazard=* tag.

Max1234-Ita commented 8 months ago

🚀 feature request

Description

I've tagged a rather dangerous place in Turkey, using the using the "hazard" tag. When tagging, I asked for advise in the mailing list on how to do it, and the current tagging is evidently the correct way to tag things.

Unfortunately, OsmAnd doesn't display the hazard, see attached screenshot below. OsmAnd does, however, display the other tag I added, displaying an icon for ruins. sshot_osmand_no_hazard_indication

End result is that my efforts may now be luring people to the area, bringing themselves in harms way, because they may fall down the hole which isn't being warned about. I'm uneasy about that.

Suggested solution

I suggest OsmAnd display a hazard-icon for nodes which has the "hazard" tag. And maybe even sound an alert, sort of like OsmAnd does when you are (for example) approaching a speed bump.

Such a feature might also be useful to warn drivers about particular spots, i.e. dangerous bends/crossings: that would really improve road safety.

A long time ago, before OsmAnd was created, I had a Tomtom navigator: I had found an additional POI category (created by a community of users) where a lot of such points were collected. It was a real help having that category active while driving around, and hearing an alert when approaching to one of them: I'm definitely missing that feature in OsmAnd.