osmandapp / OsmAnd

OsmAnd
https://osmand.net
Other
4.58k stars 1.01k forks source link

Refine announcing highway refs #19869

Open ZeljkoBG opened 3 months ago

ZeljkoBG commented 3 months ago

Add an option, trigger, so tts doesn't pronounce the number of road/street. It's just a name. Most people don't care about the number of roads. And it's irritating.

yuriiurshuliak commented 3 months ago

To achieve a more streamlined voiace guidance experience, you can customize the voice prompt settings in the OsmAnd application. By disabling options such as Street names (TTS), Exit number, Traffic warnings, Pedestrian crosswalks, and Tunnels in the voice prompts settings, you can reduce the frequency of voice instructions.

To access the voice prompt settings, go to Menu → Navigation → Settings → Sound → Settings.

ZeljkoBG commented 3 months ago

What you write has nothing to do with the pronunciation of the street name + "number of road/street".

Some applications, by default, do not read 'number of road/street' and others app have an option to turn it off (trigger).

sonora commented 3 months ago

The significance of highway numbers is extremely region-sensitive. In the US, for example, knowing the number of a US, state, or even county road will get you a long way and is very essential. In Germany, the number of motorways (Ax) or national highways (Bx) is significant, too, as found on all signing as well as in traffic announcements. While for lower hierarchy highways (e.g. "Staatsstrassen") the use of the numbers is limited to special cases only, e.g. construction crew or emergency crew maps.

Long story short, it is not easy to predict in what cases number announcement is essential vs. expendable. But I am certain it is more a regional topic than one of personal preference, e.g. the same user in different regions would in one region need numbers, in another not.

ZeljkoBG commented 3 months ago

The solution is to select a trigger. Who needs it should read it. Who should not turn off. Simple.

sonora commented 3 months ago

The solution is to select a trigger. Who needs it should read it. Who should not turn off. Simple.

Possible solution, yes. But when you read my analysis above you will find it argues that a good solution would be region-automated. While a "select trigger" (I assume you mean a user setting) would be a manual user choice, potentially an inferior solution.

ZeljkoBG commented 3 months ago

Of course it should be an option in the settings for TTS. And where else would you?

The worst option is your suggestion 'region-automated', because no application has that. 'potentially an inferior solution' - the best navigations have a selection (trigger). So 'inferior solution' has been an option for 20 years.