search

osmfoundation / welcome-mat

This is the code for the OpenStreetMap Welcome Mat website
https://welcome.openstreetmap.org/
14 stars 13 forks source link

Expand Who are the contributors? #17

Open yvecai opened 6 years ago

yvecai commented 6 years ago

The current text quoted below is a bit short about the volunteers, it could be more attractive. "Contributors: people who add or update data on OpenStreetMap. The majority of these are volunteers; some are humanitarian workers or are employed by companies."

yvecai commented 6 years ago

Could something be built from the 'mapper of the month' series?

mikelmaron commented 6 years ago

@yvecai do you have a suggestion for the text? It could link to mapper of the month if there's a list of all of them.

yvecai commented 6 years ago

A few relevant links: Mapper of the month (MOTM) project page on OSM.be: https://www.osm.be/2017/01/06/en-project-motm.html

List of posts on the wiki: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/WikiProject_Belgium/Belgian_Mapper_of_the_Month

Blogs posts on github : https://github.com/osmbe/website/tree/master/_posts

Cced to Escada for the best way to link those posts.

woodpeck commented 6 years ago

Please dear god no. I'm happy with the Belgians choosing whoever they want for mapper of the month, but the choices have in the past occasionally demonstrated very bad judgement, selectiong individuals that were and are outright damaging to OSM. This is not something we want to highlight.

yvecai commented 6 years ago

Hmm, maybe yes. However it's the project I know that focuses on people, is there something else? Another option could be a small list of quotes from users, taken with permission from MOTM or somewhere else.

mikelmaron commented 6 years ago

Let’s keep this simple. If you have 1 good specific sentence to add to that bullet in the article, please suggest it

simonpoole commented 6 years ago

Somehow "The majority of these are volunteers; some are humanitarian workers or are employed by companies" rings wrong. It is not just the majority of OSM contributors, it is 99% (at least), nothing against mentioning corporate contributors but it should be in a way that makes the proportions clear.

mikelmaron commented 6 years ago

Suggestions for better language are welcome.

xivk commented 5 years ago

@woodpeck Any feedback on the selection of mappers for MOTM is welcome, but I don't think we ever received any. If you want an interview, that shouldn't be a problem.

gplv2 commented 5 years ago

choices have in the past occasionally demonstrated very bad judgement

demonstrated where, how ? We are open for improvement but pretending that there is a huge bunch of people that agree with this claim doesn't add weight as we haven't received any. Since this is a bit off-topic too, feel free to send us your feedback and constructive criticism.