Open c-leitner opened 3 years ago
From the license:
Nota de Origen. A los efectos de utilizar los datos abiertos y metadatos abiertos en los términos referidos en el artículo anterior se deberá en todos los casos citar la siguiente información:
- el nombre del proveedor,
- la referencia a la "Licencia de Datos Abiertos – Uruguay".
- la referencia al conjunto de datos que está siendo utilizado. Los cambios, las ediciones, los nuevos diseños o modificaciones deben ser mencionados en la nota de origen.
Google Translate:
Note of Origin. In order to use open data and open metadata in the terms referred to in the previous article must in all cases cite the following information:
- the name of the provider,
- the reference to the "Open Data License - Uruguay".
- the reference to the data set that is being used. Changes, edits, new designs or modifications must be mentioned in the note of origin.
Does this need a waiver for the attribution?
https://josm.openstreetmap.de/wiki/Maps/Uruguay#IDE.uyOrtophotos2019 refers to https://www.gub.uy/agencia-gobierno-electronico-sociedad-informacion-conocimiento/sites/agencia-gobierno-electronico-sociedad-informacion-conocimiento/files/documentos/publicaciones/licencia_de_datos_abiertos_0.pdf I got the current version directly from the website: https://www.gub.uy/agencia-gobierno-electronico-sociedad-informacion-conocimiento/comunicacion/publicaciones/licencia-datos-abiertos-uruguay-0 Could be an old Version in JOSM
From the license:
Nota de Origen. A los efectos de utilizar los datos abiertos y metadatos abiertos en los términos referidos en el artículo anterior se deberá en todos los casos citar la siguiente información:
- el nombre del proveedor,
- la referencia a la "Licencia de Datos Abiertos – Uruguay".
- la referencia al conjunto de datos que está siendo utilizado. Los cambios, las ediciones, los nuevos diseños o modificaciones deben ser mencionados en la nota de origen.
Google Translate:
Note of Origin. In order to use open data and open metadata in the terms referred to in the previous article must in all cases cite the following information:
- the name of the provider,
- the reference to the "Open Data License - Uruguay".
- the reference to the data set that is being used. Changes, edits, new designs or modifications must be mentioned in the note of origin.
Does this need a waiver for the attribution?
The formulation would suggest it. I will try to contact someone at the ministry to check with them and if necessary get the waiver signed. I think they have also a motivation that OSM get better in that region since the UY Government is using OSM heavily (https://visualizador.ide.uy/ideuy/core/load_public_project/ideuy/ for example as a base layer to show all kinds of data)
@c-leitner I'm sorry for the long response time. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Contributors#Uruguay includes already IDE, where it is referred to https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/File:AGESIC_confirmation_notice.png. I'm not sure what the conversation was that lead to this answer.
From the license text it looks as the data is open data but needs to be attributed. The crucial point is if they are OK with the way that OSM attributes sources using the Contributors wiki page.
I could ask Jorge (who sent the email) if he could share the conversation history to verify that this way of attributing is OK for them. I could also ask again at agesic.
@c-leitner That would be great if you could contact Jorge and ask if they were aware of how OSM attributes data and if they consent to it.
Also, there seems to be a stall PR for maybe the same dataset: https://github.com/osmlab/editor-layer-index/pull/719
OK I am going to do that. #719 is the same dataset (I think some tests are failing). I will include all the missing information from there into my PL request so there is a PL without issues.
@c-leitner updates?
URL of the imagery
https://mapas.ide.uy/geoserver-raster/ortofotos/ows?FORMAT=image/png&TRANSPARENT=TRUE&VERSION=1.1.1&SERVICE=WMS&REQUEST=GetMap&LAYERS=ORTOFOTOS_2019&STYLES=&SRS={proj}&WIDTH={width}&HEIGHT={height}&BBOX={bbox}
Two letter country code
UY
Desired layer name
Ortofotos 2018-2019 (IDEuy)
License
OGL https://www.gub.uy/agencia-gobierno-electronico-sociedad-informacion-conocimiento/sites/agencia-gobierno-electronico-sociedad-informacion-conocimiento/files/documentos/publicaciones/licencia_de_datos_abiertos_0.pdf
Is the license compatible with OSM?
Yes.
Attribution (text, URL, required?)
Yes following information is required: Infraestructura de Datos Espaciales, Licencia de Datos Abiertos – Uruguay, Ortofotos 2018-2019 (IDEuy)
Privacy policy (URL)
https://www.gub.uy/infraestructura-datos-espaciales/politica-de-privacidad
Icon
https://www.gub.uy/infraestructura-datos-espaciales/sites/infraestructura-datos-espaciales/files/inline-images/ideuy_compacto_rgb_473px_0.png
Bounding polygon
{"type":"FeatureCollection","features":[{"type":"Feature","properties":{},"geometry":{"type":"Polygon","coordinates":[[[-53.39417,-33.73912],[-53.36321,-33.73654],[-52.7723,-34.11526],[-54.84598,-35.43046],[-57.8368,-34.67596],[-57.94731,-34.50839],[-58.10591,-34.33987],[-58.32661,-34.1545],[-58.35468,-34.04255],[-58.43356,-33.91484],[-58.48687,-33.57513],[-58.44819,-33.34742],[-58.38993,-33.28049],[-58.38202,-33.12817],[-58.32557,-33.09757],[-58.16997,-33.09102],[-58.15416,-33.05485],[-58.09264,-32.99502],[-58.13014,-32.9048],[-58.17173,-32.57208],[-58.20964,-32.49023],[-58.19965,-32.38414],[-58.11897,-32.31946],[-58.10797,-32.28872],[-58.10976,-32.25882],[-58.19279,-32.16252],[-58.15555,-31.99616],[-58.21151,-31.88502],[-58.16655,-31.83213],[-58.07958,-31.80889],[-58.05117,-31.753],[-57.99045,-31.58082],[-58.01563,-31.53429],[-58.08248,-31.49754],[-58.0893,-31.45387],[-57.98953,-31.3845],[-58.00086,-31.36114],[-57.99013,-31.31653],[-57.91549,-31.21258],[-57.92309,-31.12277],[-57.88265,-31.07346],[-57.87449,-31.03768],[-57.91342,-30.95708],[-57.91249,-30.92896],[-57.88545,-30.90965],[-57.81848,-30.91097],[-57.81523,-30.70483],[-57.84823,-30.66661],[-57.85598,-30.62477],[-57.89666,-30.58898],[-57.8969,-30.51973],[-57.848,-30.46047],[-57.65198,-30.33447],[-57.62623,-30.2508],[-57.65546,-30.18887],[-57.62208,-30.17726],[-57.55556,-30.20287],[-57.54561,-30.23006],[-57.55656,-30.25322],[-57.52148,-30.27576],[-57.46416,-30.25602],[-57.41239,-30.26915],[-57.37351,-30.26382],[-57.3491,-30.26973],[-57.31343,-30.24786],[-57.26076,-30.25694],[-57.17194,-30.23258],[-57.1769,-30.19318],[-57.10241,-30.08319],[-56.86723,-30.06385],[-56.64675,-30.19962],[-56.48435,-30.33677],[-56.48647,-30.38426],[-56.45595,-30.37685],[-56.43652,-30.42235],[-56.41135,-30.42169],[-56.38793,-30.4441],[-55.7272,-30.93064],[-55.66499,-30.85799],[-55.64115,-30.8379],[-55.57395,-30.82386],[-55.53884,-30.88318],[-55.48042,-30.9196],[-55.03716,-31.26212],[-54.99902,-31.25958],[-54.7533,-31.41455],[-54.66672,-31.44411],[-54.58167,-31.44799],[-54.49515,-31.5203],[-54.44391,-31.59583],[-54.44269,-31.64897],[-54.09106,-31.9203],[-54.03301,-31.88543],[-53.96594,-31.90848],[-53.95458,-31.94696],[-53.84307,-31.9933],[-53.73821,-32.07166],[-53.71537,-32.0953],[-53.4577,-32.47652],[-53.44727,-32.51761],[-53.39024,-32.57522],[-53.36665,-32.56037],[-53.28722,-32.61118],[-53.27332,-32.59512],[-53.24477,-32.59553],[-53.23283,-32.62039],[-53.18117,-32.63624],[-53.08408,-32.72221],[-53.17261,-32.823],[-53.28527,-32.90351],[-53.29632,-32.96987],[-53.46784,-33.07679],[-53.51141,-33.14506],[-53.51996,-33.20665],[-53.49112,-33.4279],[-53.52106,-33.66162],[-53.51577,-33.67975],[-53.43607,-33.68487],[-53.42085,-33.73068],[-53.39417,-33.73912]]]}}]}