osmlab / editor-layer-index

A unified layer index for OSM editors.
https://osmlab.github.io/editor-layer-index/
Other
222 stars 258 forks source link

MapMetrics #1316

Closed Lee-Carre closed 1 year ago

Lee-Carre commented 3 years ago

Category

Overlay. QA for routing.

Background info:

URL of the imagery

There are multiple tilesets comprising combinations of dates (usually per-month, with (delta|diff)s) & types (average, median, median_count). See MapMetrics Web-UI.

Example: http://mapmetrics-world.innovation.tomtom-global.com/tiles/median_count/OSM202109/{zoom}/{x}/{y}.png (source)

Values for {zoom} seem to be: 8, 10, 16. However, I've not exhaustively tested & verified those numbers.

Two letter country code

Global / World-wide

Desired layer name

“MapMetrics”(?)

License

Unclear. However, having read the FAQ, this source isn't for tracing, but simply finding areas with problematic routing. See the background info links up top.

Besides, they make the dataset available both as a compressed archive and via an API. So, seems that the intent is permissive usage. The likely goal seems to be to (enable the community to) improve OSM data.

Although I'm a non-lawyer, it might be possible to argue that the data is a derivative of OSM's, since it's the result of comparing OSM's road network data (used to produce routing paths) & the GNSS traces of actual drivers (which I think would be public domain(?) in terms of copyright, separately from privacy concerns).

Is the license compatible with OSM?

Being a QA overlay, I would think so.

Attribution (text, URL, required?)

“TomTom MapMetrics”?

I couldn't find any mention, on the site, of a required attribution string.

Privacy policy (URL)

http://www.tomtom.com/privacy/

Icon

Perhaps the site's /favicon.ico but there's probably copyright & trademark entanglements with doing that.

Bounding polygon

Data is planet-wide, so not applicable.

cicku commented 3 years ago

I don’t think Tomtom products can be used for OSM. It is just another kind of google maps.

However, an explicit waiver/statement should be obtained from Tomtom if you really think it is possible. Apple Maps uses OSM as well, but it does not mean you can use it in a reverse way.