search

osmlab / editor-layer-index

A unified layer index for OSM editors.
https://osmlab.github.io/editor-layer-index/
Other
215 stars 253 forks source link

Maxar Premium imagery seems broken #1889

Closed danieldegroot2 closed 1 year ago

danieldegroot2 commented 1 year ago

Edit: See https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/9710#issuecomment-1625302613

For discussion, refer to https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/maxar-imagery-not-working-was-maxar-is-blurred-in-id-and-other-similar-topics/100524

Details Imagery: Maxar Premium appearance: green blur, or similar layer information: date unknown tile information: tile information labels disappear immediately when loading them location: Any/World version: iD 2.25.2 live and 2.26.0-dev via netlify Browser: Any OS: Any

Imagery seems broken, or wasn't updated correctly.

Mahabarata commented 1 year ago

Same probleme in North America, Central America, South America, Africa, Europa, Asia, Australia...

But works here (left and bottom/left parts) : https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit#map=14/80.5683/-78.4274

In another area, it looks like imagery at zoom 11 and higher has disappeared (left part) : https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit#map=11/48.7984/0.2422 and imagery at zoom 12 and higher has disappeared (right part) : https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit#map=12/48.7984/0.2422

fnordson commented 1 year ago

Looks like it's not coming back soon: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/maxar-imagery-not-working-was-maxar-is-blurred-in-id-and-other-similar-topics/100524/15

cicku commented 1 year ago

The imagery itself is very low quality in general.

If Maxar won't bring it back then we will remove it.

fnordson commented 1 year ago

It may be low quality, but it's the best quality in certain parts of the world.
Especially 3rd world countries.
The permanent loss of Maxar would be a heavy blow to mapping there.

ErinBaker commented 1 year ago

It may be low quality, but it's the best quality in certain parts of the world. Especially 3rd world countries. The permanent loss of Maxar would be a heavy blow to mapping there.

Agree. In south east Asia, Maxar has been the best in terms of resolution and recency. The other imagery providers are up to 3 years old in urban capitals, for example. It's permanent loss would be detrimental.

b-unicycling commented 1 year ago

It was the most recent imagery in Ireland for the last about 5 months, blurry, but at least not 12 years old like Esri Clarity. Thankfully, Bing is catching up slowly.

danieldegroot2 commented 1 year ago

Updated links in top post. Please keep discussion here related to iD editor's functionality. Thanks for your patience in advance.

simonpoole commented 1 year ago

Please keep discussion here to iD editor's functionality.

You are joking I hope.

danieldegroot2 commented 1 year ago

It's just a reminder this repository is dedicated to the iD editor, not general editing. I'm not wishing to backseat-moderate the topic. Also, it drowns out any useful comments where I may not get mentioned (like the above).

I hope this answers your remark.

cicku commented 1 year ago

You are still joking.

Closing since it is out of scope.

grischard commented 1 year ago

Clarification from one of the maintainers: this repository is not dedicated to the iD editor. Many editors use the editor layer index, and the project aims to support all of them. The appropriate place for further discussion on this topic is https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/maxar-imagery-not-working-was-maxar-is-blurred-in-id-and-other-similar-topics/100524