osmlab / name-suggestion-index

Canonical common brand names, operators, transit and flags for OpenStreetMap.
https://nsi.guide
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
712 stars 870 forks source link

Add french convenience shop Proxi #3680

Closed pyrog closed 3 years ago

pyrog commented 4 years ago

name="Proxi" shop=convenience or ?? shop=supermarket

707 objects in OSM: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/Syv wikidata: Q3408522

bmillemathias-1a commented 4 years ago

Both are possible reading their website https://www.franchise-proximite.carrefour.com/nos-enseignes-proxi-concept

🇫🇷

2 formats Proxi : des magasins de petit format organisés autour d’un point fort attractif comme les produis frais, une station-service, de la presse… Proxi Super des commerces alimentaires plus grands organisés autour des pôles alimentaires traditionnels comme la zone marché, le point chaud, la boucherie-charcuterie…

🇬🇧

2 Proxi formats: small format stores organized around an attractive point such as fresh produce, a service station, the press, etc. Proxi Super larger food businesses organized around traditional food hubs such as the market area, the hot spot, the butcher's shop

johanricher commented 4 years ago

It's Proxi not "Proxy", and it's already added as a convenience store brand: https://github.com/osmlab/name-suggestion-index/blob/master/brands/shop/convenience.json#L1438

Proxi Super should be considered first as an addition to Wikidata, then in NSI as a supermarket brand.

pyrog commented 3 years ago

Proxy seem a duplication of Proxi.

And Proxy Super should be added in brands/shop/superkarket.json with the same wikidata item. Right ?

    {
      "displayName": "Proxi Super",
      "locationSet": {"include": ["ch", "fr"]},
      "tags": {
        "brand": "Proxi",
        "brand:wikidata": "Q3408522",
        "name": "Proxi Super",
        "shop": "supermarket"
      }
    },
johanricher commented 3 years ago

"Proxi" and "Proxi Super" are effectively sharing the same Wikidata item: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q3408522. Then "Proxi Super" should be added as a separate entry convenience.json as you described and "Proxy" should be removed.

nuxper commented 3 years ago

Done:

Note @pyrog : we actually have a high number of incorrectly named "Proxy" convenience store in France (>50). I'll edit some.