osmlab / name-suggestion-index

Canonical common brand names, operators, transit and flags for OpenStreetMap.
https://nsi.guide
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
630 stars 830 forks source link

Add public transport ticket machines in Wrocław with operator Mennica Polska #9645

Open PavLL opened 2 weeks ago

PavLL commented 2 weeks ago

{ "displayName": "Mennica Polska (Urbancard)", "locationSet": {"include": ["pl"]}, "tags": { "amenity": "vending_machine", "brand": "Urbancard", "currency:PLN": "yes", "network": "MPK Wrocław", "operator": "Mennica Polska", "operator:wikidata": "Q4371256", "payment:american_express": "yes", "payment:blik": "yes", "payment:coins": "yes", "payment:diners_club": "yes", "payment:ep_urbancard": "yes", "payment:maestro": "yes", "payment:maestro_contactless": "yes", "payment:mastercard" v="yes", "payment:mastercard_contactless" v="yes", "payment:notes": "yes", "payment:urbancard": "yes", "payment:visa": "yes", "payment:visa_contactless": "yes", "payment:visa_electron": "yes", "payment:v_pay": "yes", "vending": "public_transport_tickets" } }

bhousel commented 2 weeks ago

It looks like we already have an item for Mennica Polska that would conflict with this suggestion.. Can you say more what the difference is between the two? We could geofence them to different regions within Poland if needed?

https://nsi.guide/index.html?t=operators&k=amenity&v=vending_machine#mennicapolska-a736eb

PavLL commented 2 weeks ago

The existing Mennica Polska entry is for the ticket machines over in Warsaw and the one submitted by me is for machines in a different city, Wrocław. They do have some differences, the obvious one being that they're sold for different public transport companies (network tag) but also the ticket machines in Wrocław are vigorously associated with their own method of payment which is Urbancard and generally Mennica Polska isn't really associated here with public transport ticket machines unlike in Warsaw where there are a various ticket machine operators. I think should be enough to make a separate entry unless the goal of NSI is to just simply group stuff such as ticket machines operated by one company despite it differing a bit between cities. In such case the existing entry should have many of it's tags removed. If it's possible to link items to different regions, that'd be really nice and make things clearer.

PavLL commented 1 week ago

Hello, after doing some thinking I decided that I would like to move my entry to brands for brand=Urbancard with a display name of "Biletomat Urbancard" since it's really more about Urbancard than Mennica Polska. I would also like to have the geographic scope to be Wrocław, Poland and add one more tag: "prepaid_top_up:ep_urbancard": "yes"