Audit is not created when manually triggering the updated event on model

[omerbaskurt]

Q	A
Bug?	yes
New Feature?	no	yes
Framework	Laravel
Framework version	10.23.1
Package version	13.5.1
PHP version	8.2.12

I update a property of a model and saveQuietly to not to trigger events on the save. Then, manually fire the update event later. I expect an update audit getting triggered but it doesn't. created, restored, deleted events work as expected.

$article->title = $newTitle;
$article->saveQuietly();
...
event('eloquent.updated: App\Models\Article', $article);

updated is included in the audit config file (audit.php)

'events' => [
        'created',
        'updated',
        'deleted',
        'restored'
],

[parallels999]

Maybe it's because update uses dirty, and after saving, dirty is empty Try this way

$article->title = $newTitle;
event('eloquent.updated: App\Models\Article', $article);
$article->saveQuietly();

[omerbaskurt]

Thanks, that does the trick. But it kinda defeats the purpose of not firing events on save. We do fire the events after the business logic block. Something like this:

$article->title = $newTitle;
$article->saveQuietly();
$events[] = ['updated', 'App\Models\Article', $article];

$user->restoreQuietly();
$events[] = ['restored', 'App\Models\User', $user];

... a bunch of other operations without events while saving event data

// then fire the events
foreach ($events as $event) {
    event('eloquent.' . $event[0] . ': ' . $event[1], $event[2]);
}

[parallels999]

Did you try clone before save??

$article->title = $newTitle;
$events[] = ['updated', 'App\Models\Article', clone $article];
$article->saveQuietly();

I can't give you a specific answer if you don't specify the full scenario

[omerbaskurt]

Using clone on the event works, thank you.