own-pt / own-en-legacy

The openWordnet-EN, a converted and expanded PWN
MIT License
0 stars 1 forks source link

syntatic vs semantic links #12

Closed arademaker closed 7 years ago

arademaker commented 7 years ago
w: a LINK b

this links sense of word a with sense of word b.

link: w

this links synset with synset (using the word w of the target as reference).

how to link a word to a synset? Some links in PWN are between sense-synset.

fcbr commented 7 years ago

can you give an example in WN 3.0 of a link between a word and a synset?

arademaker commented 7 years ago

http://arademaker.github.io/files/gwc-2016-icv.pdf

I am trying the query below with reasoniong turned on. still running

select ?a ?b {
  ?a a wn30:Synset .
  ?a ?c ?b .
  ?b a wn30:WordSense .
}
arademaker commented 7 years ago

note that the data file format (http://wordnet.princeton.edu/wordnet/man/wndb.5WN.html) can contains this kind of link.

but the lexicographer files may not

{ [ personhood, noun.Tops:person,+ ] identity,@ (being a person; "finding her own personhood as a campus activist") }

so maybe our modeling is wrong and the links are between sense-sense or synset-synset but not between sense-synset and synset-sense. if that is the case, our https://github.com/own-pt/openWordnet-PT/blob/master/wn30.ttl.

arademaker commented 7 years ago

ok, it seems that no synset-sense or sense-synset exists.

egrep " 000[1-9] " data.* 
egrep " 0[1-9]00 " data.* 

We need to refine our wn30.ttl model.

fcbr commented 7 years ago

Looks like there is no issue here, then.