No tracks listed in any of the synced albums

r3dpl4te commented 6 months ago

Hi, I originally reported this bug to Symfonium forum, a music player for e.g. subsonic servers, as implemented in Music App for Nextcloud.

The main problem is that there are no tracks listed in any of the albums synced.

If I click on the Artists name I can find the tracks available. Please see screenshots below.

I'll link to the forum if it's ok: https://support.symfonium.app/t/no-tracks-listed-in-any-of-the-synced-albums/3512/2 Quote from @Tolriq : "The logs are strange, the server returns the same data multiple times, they probably miss a sort leading to random result. "

In compatibility mode it works like a charme, but for bigger databases I guess it could be lead into problems with no fast syncing.

Information:

Subsonic API 1.10.0 Music App
Nextcloud 28.0.2 Stable
Meta data scanning enabled on both server and client or simply folder structure for some files listed im a simple folder
No filter (at least not that I know)
If you need any logs, tell me. I couldn't find any in the nextcloud apps/music folder.
Id3 tags are/should be properly added or original added by e.g. audible. I checked them with different tag editors.
And there is no difference in audio format. Reported behavior counts for mp3 and mb4 in this case.

Below screenshots

Thank you very much If you need anything more, just let me know. Besides that it works just great♥️ Kind regards Wood

paulijar commented 6 months ago

We were discussing this issue elsewhere with @Tolriq. If I understood it correctly, the root cause for this is because Nextcloud Music uses the musicFolderId argument in a way which is not strictly wrong but maybe a bit surprising and untypical, and Symfonium wasn't prepared for this. I believe that @Tolriq was planning to make a change on the Symfonium client and this shouldn't need changes on Nextcloud Music.

Tolriq commented 6 months ago

Version 9.0 have a workaround yes, and the issue is not much the values but the fact that there's 2 identical folders that returns the same data. Since you are OS compatible and return the server type it's possible to detect and workaround so if no other apps did complain I guess there's nothing to change (My workaround is based on your comment that if you properly support folders one day you'll use positive values and no duplicates)

paulijar commented 6 months ago

Apparently Symfonium v9.0 is already released so could you give it a try @r3dpl4te?

r3dpl4te commented 6 months ago

Hi! I could indeed and run through the changelogs. Thank you very much @Tolriq & @paulijar , looks like the workaorund/fix, that comes with 9.00 b12584 works 👍 :)

if you need any more logs or information to fix on server side, just hit me up.
But as far as I could check every album lists the tracks properly now.

Regards, redplate

Edit: I see :) https://github.com/opensubsonic/open-subsonic-api/pull/84#issuecomment-1947312239 👍

paulijar commented 6 months ago

Great, thanks for the verification!

owncloud / music

No tracks listed in any of the synced albums #1131