pacific-hake / hake-assessment

:zap: :fish: Build the assessment document using latex and knitr
MIT License
13 stars 6 forks source link

Remove emphasis/detail regarding 2010 cohort from document/presentations #1038

Closed kellijohnson-NOAA closed 10 months ago

kellijohnson-NOAA commented 1 year ago

For the 2024 assessment the emphasis on the 2010 cohort should be decreased given that they are over a decade old.

From Trevor's comments in #1031

andrew-edwards commented 10 months ago

There's actually a few different ideas here getting slightly mixed up. Based on the above tickboxes:

  1. Text at bottom of page 60 (last year's assessment) - I think he's referring to "The very strong 2010 year class comprised 64% of the coast-wide commercial catch in 2014...." and other catch years. Agree that can go (as not likely to change from assessment to assessment anyway), and it's already been deleted. The 'detailed examination of 2010 v 2014' is the paragraph on my scaled recruitment figure, for which the point is understanding relative strengths (not caring about 2010 v 2014 per se), so I can clarify that up front. See discussion on 26b393d.
  2. Table 33-35: 2020 recruitment was already in those tables. So 2010 could be deleted because it's somewhat old, but also could certainly be kept in as it's (almost certainly) the largest since 1980 and so is a valuable reference. I think it might be valuable to keep in (although values are in other tables, so not essential).
  3. See discussion on 26b393d. I think Trevor missed the presentation a couple of years back about the motivation for the figure. I can certainly change the text though.
    Sorry, I hadn't got to thinking about these issues yet.