Change 'Sign Up' to 'Apply for an Account'

participedia / api

Website and API for Participedia V3

https://participedia.net

MIT License

20 stars 14 forks source link

Change 'Sign Up' to 'Apply for an Account' #1147

Closed jesicarson closed 6 months ago

jesicarson commented 11 months ago

Issue: we're seeing about 10 daily spam user accounts, with over 10K in the database. I'd guess 90% of these are spam. If you google search for one of the spam keywords, their participedia profile may come up in search results.

Feature ideas:

Make adding a bio a requirement, ie: if the bio doesn't express why the user should have an account on Participedia, we won't approve them. (will need to figure out how this works in other languages)
Require admin approval for all new user account requests

Challenges:

languages
barrier to participation
person required to do the review (staff time, training)
this system could still be hacked - if real people are doing the spam accounts, they could draft misleading requests for an account and later edit their profile to be spam

jesicarson commented 11 months ago

Maybe the language could be "Join our community of editors"

Also doing some research, ie: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Spam

jesicarson commented 11 months ago

https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Nofollow

On 18 January 2005 the Google blog entry "Preventing comment spam" declared that Google would henceforth respect a rel="nofollow" attribute on hyperlinks. Their page ranking algorithm now ignores links with this attribute when ranking the destination page. The intended result is that site administrators can modify user-posted links such that the attribute is present, and thus an attempt to googlebomb by posting a link on such a site would yield no increase from that link.

jesicarson commented 11 months ago

We're getting about 5 spam user profiles daily, who are all attempting to publish entries, making the review entries task more difficult and complicated. I'm thinking we should close down the site - no new users. Add a message about emailing us to apply to become an editor, something like this. It's becoming un-manageable. Let's discuss on Monday @paninee

paninee commented 10 months ago

@jesicarson The "sign Up" label is part of auth0. I dont' know if we can change it, and if that's going to help with spams.

The last time we chatted, we decided not to shut down the site, please let me know if that changes.

jesicarson commented 10 months ago

Yes we decided against this approach, in favor of adding nofollow to user profiles. This can probably be closed.