pascallanger / DIY-Multiprotocol-TX-Module

Multiprotocol TX Module (or MULTI-Module) is a 2.4GHz transmitter module which controls many different receivers and models.
https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2165676&goto=newpost
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.62k stars 436 forks source link

Hott protocol, how to define SUMD output #985

Closed pierrotm777 closed 2 months ago

pierrotm777 commented 4 months ago

Hello,

I use the Hott protocol with a Graupner GR-24 Pro receiver. With a true Graupner handset, it's possible to define the channel 8 as SUMD signal. SUMD (Signal cumulé numérique) au canal 6 (GR-24PRO canal 8) Si le signal cumulé numérique est activé au niveau du canal 6 le signal cumulé est émis (au lieu d'un servo) avec 8 canaux à partir de cette prise. Le récepteur HoTT configuré en tant que SUMD génère en permanence un signal cumulé numérique à partir de 8 signaux de commande de l'émetteur et le prépare au niveau du raccord de servo défini spécifiquement pour le récepteur. Un tel signal est utilisé pour des équipements électroniques dans le cadre des nouveaux systèmes Flybarless et alimentations Power. This feature don't exist for this protocol. Should it be possible to add it ?

Thanks,

Pierre

pascallanger commented 4 months ago

I would need a dump of the TX with the feature disabled/enabled.

pierrotm777 commented 4 months ago

Ok, i need to compile with the debug option as we have done with the hitec protocol ? I see that with a guy how has a Graupner transmitter and send you a dump file asap. Thanks, Pierre

pascallanger commented 4 months ago

Humm that's not that as simple as you write it down. 2 options:

  1. Easy for me/Moderate for you: open the Graupner TX and connect a logic analyzer on the CC2500, do a dump and share
  2. Moderate to Hard for me/Easy for you: develop a RX on Multi to receive the HoTT packets and ouput them on debug for analyze
pierrotm777 commented 4 months ago

In fact, I understand just that now. I think another way is possible by programing directly the receiver with a serial interface. You can close this issue if you want. But thanks for your quick answer.

pierrotm777 commented 4 months ago

How yes, a Rx option would be may be the solution for me

pierrotm777 commented 4 months ago

With that solution, my Tx16s would use zRx Hott protocol and I should bind it with an original Graupner handset?

pascallanger commented 4 months ago

yes this is solution 2 how to, with debug enabled and post the output here

pierrotm777 commented 4 months ago

Ok

pierrotm777 commented 3 months ago

Hello Pascal, I had speak about my goal to a friend. I see if it's hansed has the sumd design. Say me please when you Rx hott will be ready for this test. Thanks again, Pierre

mha1 commented 2 months ago

just use the Graupner HoTT LUA to configure the RX to output SUMD just like you would do with a genuine Graupner transmitter: https://github.com/pascallanger/DIY-Multiprotocol-TX-Module/releases/download/v1.3.4.0/MultiLuaScripts.zip

pierrotm777 commented 2 months ago

Thanks for this share 👍

mha1 commented 2 months ago

Howto assuming you are using OpenTX or EdgeTX (pictures show EdgeTX on a TX16s connected to a GR16 receiver):

image

image

Check the Graupner manual for the receiver you are using as the receiver config pages look different depending on the receiver.

pierrotm777 commented 2 months ago

I have downloaded the Graupner Hott script and i haven't the same script than you. I can only use channel 8 for SUMD output but i should like to use the channel 10.

pascallanger commented 2 months ago

The full menu is sent by the RX itself and displayed on the radio. That's why the display can be very different. If it only proposes sumd on ch8 then that's what it supports. You might look at upgrading the RX fw version but I doubt it will make a difference as this might be a hardware limitation on it.

pierrotm777 commented 2 months ago

Ok, thanks for these infos. I have already updated my receiver. I keep the only channel 8 witch run well as sumd output for me.

mha1 commented 2 months ago

The full menu is sent by the RX itself and displayed on the radio. That's why the display can be very different. If it only proposes sumd on ch8 then that's what it supports. You might look at upgrading the RX fw version but I doubt it will make a difference as this might be a hardware limitation on it.

Yes, check the Graupner receiver manuals. All Graupner receivers I know can only use a specific channel for SBUS or SUMD output. Which cannel it is depends on the receiver type. Check the manuals.

pierrotm777 commented 2 months ago

Ok, I see that. Thanks

mha1 commented 2 months ago

Also the menus look different depending on the receiver type. But if you know the original Graupner system you sure know all this too. If not, just read the Graupner manuals.