[TerraBlender Compatibility] Biomes are not loading

mxskedmystery commented 2 years ago

What happened?

I went into the nether on a single-player world and used /locatebiome to find one of the new biomes. after multiple failed attempts I loaded a new single-player and had the same issue. I thought it was a mod creating structures (Repurposed Structures (Fabric)) conflicting with it, so I uninstalled it and tried again. the same result "couldn't find biome." So I redownloaded the mod, thinking I accidentally got rid of something, but still had the same issue. I don't know why none of the biomes are spawning. all of the creatures are spawning as well as the nether cities. can someone please help?

BetterNether

5.0.9

BCLib

1.2.5

Fabric API

0.46.1

Fabric Loader

0.12.12

Minecraft

1.18.1

Relevant log output

No response

Other Mods

Adorn
BetterEnd
Cloth API (Fabric)
Cloth Config API (Fabric)
Comforts (Fabric)
Croptopia [FABRIC/FORGE]
End Origins
Enhanced Celestials(Fabric) - Blood Moons & Harvest Moons
Extra Origins
Fabric API
Fabric Language Kotlin
Fabric Waystones
Galacticborn Origin
Grounded Origins [FABRIC]
Iris Shaders
Mob Origins
Mythical Origins
Oh The Biomes You'll Go Refabricated
Origins (Fabric)
Paintings ++
Patchouli (Fabric)
Pehkui
Plushie Mod
Simple Backpack [FABRIC]
Simple Voice Chat
Sodium
TerraBlender (Fabric)
TotalHero's custom origins
Repurposed Structures (Fabric)

paulevsGitch commented 2 years ago

Try to re-enter into same world again and search for the biomes. Allow BCLib fix biome source on world loading

quiqueck commented 2 years ago

Both BCLib and TerraBlender want to change the same thing. Until we come up with a fix, those Mod will be incompatible as either one will override the results of the other. We starte to talk with the other devs, but I can not estimate when we will have a solution for this.

Sunconure11 commented 2 years ago

Dumb question, but is there a reason not to use TerraBlender to do the same approach of what you were previously doing?

paulevsGitch commented 2 years ago

BetterNether & BetterEnd have different biome generation that is not compatible with Terrablender. Terrablender biomes can be imported into it, but not visa versa

StockiesLad commented 2 years ago

Dude Promenade, BYG have nether stuff just sitting there because terrablender and bclib hate eachother

paulevsGitch commented 2 years ago

Promenade don't use TerraBlender, it uses Fabric API (at least version that I testes). BetterNether and BetterEnd can work with BYG, but for Nether/End you need to manually add biomes into config.

Library compat is not an easy thing that can be done with one button press. There is Fabric Biome API that exists since 1.16 and allows mods to add biomes together into Nether and End, BCLib, BN, BE and Promenade uses it and works fine. Terrablender and BYG - not, they work only with their own biome source

StockiesLad commented 2 years ago

Promenade requires terrablender for the biomes to spawn so it is essentially dependant on it. This library compat can be done with promenade as well right?

StockiesLad commented 2 years ago

How do I even get the biomes into bc lib for better end and nether

paulevsGitch commented 2 years ago

How do I even get the biomes

There are two solutions. First is activation of "addEndBiomesByCategory" in generator.json:

"addEndBiomesByCategory [default: false]": true,

And the second is manual biome adding into forces biomes lists in biomes.json:

"force_include": {
  "end_land_biomes": ["mod:cool_end_land_biome","mod:another_cool_end_land_biome"],
  "end_void_biomes": ["mod:cool_end_void_biome"],
  "nether_biomes": ["mod:nether_biome","mod:another_nether_biome"]
},

Sunconure11 commented 2 years ago

Would this apply to Terralith, too? Given how some oddities have been reported with it and Terrablender and possibly this mod here and there.

paulevsGitch commented 2 years ago

BCLib doesn't affect Overworld, so issues of Terralith and Terrablender are not related to it

Sunconure11 commented 2 years ago

Is there a similar config option for Better Nether? Either that or I'm not seeing it.

paulevsGitch commented 2 years ago

If you mean biomes and generator - these options are BClib options, not BetterNether

StockiesLad commented 2 years ago

How do I even get the biomes

There are two solutions. First is activation of "addEndBiomesByCategory" in generator.json:
"addEndBiomesByCategory [default: false]": true,
And the second is manual biome adding into forces biomes lists in biomes.json:
"force_include": {
  "end_land_biomes": ["mod:cool_end_land_biome","mod:another_cool_end_land_biome"],
  "end_void_biomes": ["mod:cool_end_void_biome"],
  "nether_biomes": ["mod:nether_biome","mod:another_nether_biome"]
},

Thank you so much!

paulevsGitch / BetterNether