pfalcon / zim-desktop-wiki-markdown

pfalcon's fork of Zim desktop wiki project - quick Markdown format support for notebooks, usability improvements, etc. Everything WIP.
http://zim-wiki.org
GNU General Public License v2.0
30 stars 3 forks source link

Unsupported/not yet supported Markdow features #2

Open pfalcon opened 3 years ago

pfalcon commented 3 years ago

Things to support (checked - supported, unchecked - unsupported):

FernandoBasso commented 3 years ago

I have been using a Notebook with Markdown for about a week now and it has been working fine. Your work is much appreciated! Thanks a lot for this effort.

pfalcon commented 3 years ago

@FernandoBasso: Thanks for the feedback, glad it's working for you!

Korodny commented 2 years ago

I assume Github flavoured Markdown is the standard you're aiming for?

While Github's "fenced" code blocks (three backticks above and below a block of preformatted text) are supported, original Markdown's approach - which is also supported by Github - of indenting a paragraph by four spaces to mark it as preformatted text is not supported. That would certainly be nice to have.

Of course, supporting quoted text would be very nice as well, but that would require changes in the official branch, so this is impossible for now.

pfalcon commented 2 years ago

I assume Github flavoured Markdown is the standard you're aiming for?

I'm not really aiming for anything, except for having a tool to maintain my Markdown-based personal knowledgebase. I originally wanted to write such myself, but then found Zim, which had nice UI, but was completely useless to me with its proprietary text format. So, I hacked up some Markdown support on top of it (enough for me), and that get me much further than if I wrote a thing from scratch. But neither my hack nor the underlying Zim itself is anything like perfect. I'm more or less ok with that, as for me the most important is my data (and access to it), not a tool. Surely, I'd like to improve the tool, but likely that would take someone else to join in and push along...

While Github's "fenced" code blocks (three backticks above and below a block of preformatted text) are supported, original Markdown's approach - which is also supported by Github - of indenting a paragraph by four spaces to mark it as preformatted text is not supported. That would certainly be nice to have.

I personally don't miss that. And as I mentioned elsewhere, a proper way to resolve things like that would be to plug in a proper Markdown parser (external module).

Of course, supporting quoted text would be very nice as well, but that would require changes in the official branch, so this is impossible for now.

Ack, that's what I miss myself, and would look into one of these years.

rc-mfierro commented 2 years ago

This has been a lifesaver, thanks @pfalcon for the time you've put into this! Block-quotes don't work exactly the way I had expected though, are they an officially supported markdown tag?

pfalcon commented 2 years ago

I'm using both

`foo`

and

```
foo
```

here.