search

pfefferniels / probstuecke-data

This repository contains the MEI and TEI encodings of Probstücke Digital
http://probstuecke-digital.de
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
1 stars 2 forks source link

Clef changes #32

Closed rettinghaus closed 8 months ago

rettinghaus commented 1 year ago

Currently the original clef changes are overwritten with the values for normalized clefs. That leads to the same clef repeatedly popping up all over the score.

I would propose to keep the original clef changes in orig so we can directly filter them out.

pfefferniels commented 1 year ago

Thanks and sorry for the late reply! I'm not sure if I understand you correctly: is the idea to simply remove all <orig>s in order to show modern clefs? I think that wouldn't work, since high C clefs, alt and soprano, are replaced with a violin clef, while tenor and bariton clef become bass clefs – but with removing the original clef changes, everything will become a bass clef (or whatever is given in the beginning). But probably I just didn't get your idea 🧐

(And of course you're right: the repeating modern clefs are quite ugly …)

rettinghaus commented 1 year ago

You're right, I didn't thought of those.

So we should wrap them in choice elements and regularize the clef changes like we did with figured bass, just the other way around, that the original is encoded first.