pharo-project / pharo

Pharo is a dynamic reflective pure object-oriented language supporting live programming inspired by Smalltalk.
http://pharo.org
Other
1.2k stars 356 forks source link

New icons looks worse than older on Windows #12021

Open NSUSpray opened 1 year ago

NSUSpray commented 1 year ago

Bug description I compare Pharo-11.0.0+build.269 and latest Pharo-11.0.0+build.346 and see that there are new icons, and they are more blurry, dirty and unbalanced.

To Reproduce

  1. Open a System Browser in build 269
  2. Open a System Browser in build 346
  3. Visually compare icons

Expected behavior New icons should be at least no worse than the old ones.

Screenshots

build 269 build 346
The minimize icon has become too fat, the close icon a bit too.
Gone is the beautiful one pixel gap between the blue dot and the brown frame on the left.
The bottom side of the triangle has become blurry.
The radio button has become a little more blurry and is no longer aligned nicely in the middle of the line.
Instead of a stylish and light icon, the graphics became so rough, as if it was drawn in MS Paint.

Version information:

Ducasse commented 1 year ago

On which windows are you watching them? Because they are from vector graphic version. So may be we have a conversion problem or a rendering issue. They are crisp on my machine

Capture 2022-11-30 at 20 51 39
astares commented 1 year ago

Looking really good (sharp and clean) on the windows machines that I use:

image

@NSUSpray Did you update the VM and related libraries?

astares commented 1 year ago

If I use a different scale factor other than 1.0 they look more blurred instead of being nice and sharp (which one would expect from a scaled SVG to still look sharp)

image

astares commented 1 year ago

Screenshot of a scale factor of 2.0

image

NSUSpray commented 1 year ago

If I use a different scale factor other than 1.0 they look more blurred instead of being nice and sharp (which one would expect from a scaled SVG to still look sharp)

Blurring when scaling in the OS is another issue. I’m talking about the quality of icons for 100% scale in the OS.

NSUSpray commented 1 year ago

Looking really good (sharp and clean) on the windows machines that I use:

Looks not so good

изображение

astares commented 4 months ago

@NSUSpray Still relevant? Did you check in Pharo 12/Pharo 13?

NSUSpray commented 4 months ago

@astares, yes, I already checked, it’s still relevant.