Rich attributes fpi, see, and possibly others are not returned in svrl report

[Michiel-s]

Hi @phax,

First of all, thanks for this great schematron validation implementation.

I'm using version 5.6.0.

When I have e.g. the following rule set

<sch:pattern id="1000101">
   <sch:title>Rule title</sch:title>
   <sch:rule id="1000101" fpi="BR-123" context="some xpath here">
      <sch:assert fpi="BR123-1" flag="error" see="#/rules/1000101" test="some test here">Some error message here</sch:assert>
    </sch:rule>
</sch:pattern>

The attribute fpi (both for rule and assert) and see are not returned in the svrl output:

<ns2:schematron-output title="" schemaVersion="">
    <ns2:active-pattern id="1000101" name="Rule title" document=""/>
    <ns2:fired-rule id="1000101" context="some xpath here"/>
    <ns2:fired-rule id="1000101" context="some xpath here"/>
    <ns2:failed-assert location="xpath location" test="the test again" flag="error">
        <ns2:text>Some error message here</ns2:text>
    </ns2:failed-assert>
</ns2:schematron-output>

As you can see, the id and flag attributes are there, but not the fpi and see. They are part of the schematron and svrl specs and I also see some references to those attributes in your code.

Is this a bug, feature or am I missing some config that I need to use.

Michiel

[phax]

Hi Michiel, thanks for your question. May I ask what version of the Schematron engine you are using? Pure, SCH or XSLT? Because that has an impact on the outcome :) Thanks, Philip

[Michiel-s]

I’m not using the Pure engine, but not sure what you mean by SCH vs XSLT. I’m creating a new schematron resource with SchematronResourceSCH class. So I think the SCH engine then. But as far as I understood and see in the logs, this translates to xslt for the actual validation process.

[phax]

Yes exactly - the SCH is converted to an XSLT and than applied onto the main XML to created SVRL. In that case I cannot help you, as this is basically the "default XSLT" from schematron.com (see https://github.com/Schematron/schematron ) I scanned the issues but couldn't find something.... Please open an issue there - okay?

[phax]

Closing this, as there is unfortunately not much I can do here :(

[flowrider3000]

@Michiel-s check my pr #111 for an example how to add allow-foreign elements.

[Michiel-s]

Thx. I'll look into it probably Monday. Thanks for mentioning me.

[phax]

My SVRL output is currently this:

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="no"?>
<schematron-output xmlns="http://purl.oclc.org/dsdl/svrl" schemaVersion="" title="">
<!--   
           
           
         -->
  <active-pattern document="C:\dev\git\ph-schematron\ph-schematron\src\test\resources\issues\github101\test.xml" id="p1000101" name="Rule title" />
  <fired-rule context="/doc/h1" fpi="BR-123" id="r1000101" />
  <failed-assert flag="error" fpi="BR123-1" location="/doc[1]/h1[1]" see="#/rules/1000101" test="@a='b'">
    <text>Some error message here</text>
  </failed-assert>
  <fired-rule context="/doc/h1" fpi="BR-123" id="r1000101" />
  <fired-rule context="/doc/h1" fpi="BR-123" id="r1000101" />
  <failed-assert flag="error" fpi="BR123-1" location="/doc[1]/h1[3]" see="#/rules/1000101" test="@a='b'">
    <text>Some error message here</text>
  </failed-assert>
</schematron-output>

it fails because attribute fpi is not allowed in svrl:fired-rule

[phax]

It should be working in the 6.0.0 version

[flowrider3000]

@phax many thanks. Do you have any eta when 6.0.0 will be available?

[phax]

No not really. I am splitting things into more modules and want to add schxslt as well - if this is done, v6 is free to be published

[phax]

Version 6.0.0 is on it's way to Maven Central. Please see https://github.com/phax/ph-schematron/wiki/Migrations for details