search

phenaproxima / starshot-prototype

Prototype of a new kind of Drupal, based on recipes and loaded up with contrib's best modules and themes. Not a fork or a distribution.
https://drupal.org/starshot
102 stars 34 forks source link

As a distribution builder or site builder, I want the recipes included in Drupal CMS to be available as standalone packages so that I can reuse them in my distribution or site without using Drupal CMS's scaffold project. #71

Open balsama opened 1 month ago

balsama commented 1 month ago

70 implies that all of the recipes will be developed in a monolith repo (as it is currently). But we should have automation that splits the atomic Recipes into their own repos for distribution so that they can be reused outside of the scaffold project for both distribution builders and individual site builders.

phenaproxima commented 1 month ago

Yup, agreed on this. I'm not sure how to set up the subtree split, but at least there's prior art on that. This is most definitely blocked until Starshot finds its permanent home under DA control (most likely on GitLab...at least, that's what I hope for).

phenaproxima commented 1 month ago

Just for visibility - this is something I discussed with Alex Pott. The current plan is for all recipes (yes, all recipes, everywhere) to be their own tiny Composer packages -- this prevents ambiguity and package nesting, which is a pure Drupalism that needs to die.

Starshot would then be bifurcated into:

  1. A metapackage that brings in all the component recipes but provides nothing of its own. This is the same thing drupal/core-recommended does.
  2. A template project that sets up Starshot with quick installs, DDEV/Lando integration, etc.
simesy commented 1 month ago

Why wouldn't (in time) all the recipes used by starshot just be avaialble in the project browser, or whatever tool will be used for recipes in Extend.

phenaproxima commented 1 month ago

@simesy: I think that is, eventually, the exact aim. But there's a lot of infrastructure that needs to happen for that first, across several initiatives and at the DA's end.

simesy commented 1 month ago

Yes agreed, i see how it's a good thing at this point (and a good feature in general) to have default recipes in the same repo.

phenaproxima commented 1 week ago

This was sorta-kinda done in #109. Obviously the recipes aren't coming from Packagist, but now this is an example of how one could create a recipe as a small package and compose recipes together.