phenaproxima
commented
1 month ago I think I have some concerns with this module. I don't have time to go into them right now, but a quick list:
- The scope of the module's functionality is very unclear; "doing one thing well" is better, from a composition perspective, then "one module to rule them all".
- It seems to follow a "freemium" model, which I'm not sure is desirable for Starshot.
- The initial 1.0.x commit was two years ago, and there are less than 500 sites reporting that they use this module, so the battle-testedness seems dubious.
- The use of AI raises concerns about privacy, usefulness, etc.
- The code itself seems to lack anything beyond a configuration form and some minor hooks. It's not clear how it actually implements the purported accessibility improvements.
- There are no automated tests.
So to be honest, my initial impulse is not to accept this module. But I don't have time to research it deeply, and I could be wrong here. Leaving this open for others to comment.
Websites should be accessible to individuals with disabilities, ensuring equal access to information and services. Ethically, accessible websites promote inclusivity, allowing all users, regardless of their abilities, to engage fully with digital content.
The module https://www.drupal.org/project/all_in_one_accessibility provides many features that improve Drupal website ADA compliance and browser experience.