search

philbowles / PangolinMQTT

PangolinMQTT - ArduinoIDE client library for ESP8266, ESP32 and STM32-NUCLEO
Other
71 stars 21 forks source link

1.0.1 does not work properly on ESP32, causes "PANIC" somethimes on reconnect #34

Open wladwnt opened 3 years ago

wladwnt commented 3 years ago

ESP32: I had issues with 0.9 Version, but with 1.0.1 it is worser. I do lot of stress tests, enabling/disabling many times WLAN router, killing MQTT server, emulating very poor WiFi signal etc. V1.0.1 crashes (causing ESP_RST_PANIC) much oftner than V0.9 did. In total, it happens approximately each 50st. event, so definately not each time and is not really reproducable (that why is hard to trace what exactely happens). Yes, I publish only if WiFi is connected, only when free heap is enough, only if TXQ size is not too big, hav payloads length only max. 128 bytes, ..... Maybe the issue is the AsyncTCP used by PangolinMQTT, I dont know.

So, for now, I mooved back to original ESP-IDF v3.3 MQTT implementation. It has some disadvantages, but absolutely stable. PangolinMQTT is basicaly great Lib, but at least fro ESP32 must reach higher maturity.

HamzaHajeir commented 1 year ago

Hi @wladwnt, I'm sorry to tell you the passage of Philbowles (~ a year ago).

And happy to inform you with maintaining and continuation of his work.

You can check H4AsyncMQTT for the MQTT, and you can check for the other stack members within a complete PlatformIO environment in H4Plugins_Env