dannyndang
commented
7 years ago Team A8
Danny Dang I wish your UI was a little bit more clear and cohesive. The cows are novel to your app, but the bubbles that presents data isn't very clear at all. I would prefer something that was more cohesive, so maybe change the colors or the shape of the bubbles. Additionally, there should be a way to turn on and off the amount of descriptions available rather than have them all up on the screen at once. It is very cluttered if everything is up there. Otherwise I think it works out well.
Hon Lao I like that the UI is very simple and self explanatory, it looks very fluid and the overall asethetic is good. I wish that the action buttons for placing different markers can located in a more prime spot, right now its in the left. Also I wish that the icon for your event and others events look different so its easily distinguishable
Robert Ferng: I wish your ui had more option to distinguish each drop from the other. Ex. Sale drop will be colored green and food drops will be colored red. I like how everything looks really clean and simple. The upvote and downvote icons are not arrows but are still simple enough for people to recognize it as up and down vote
Karthik: I really liked the addition of the login screen and how you can filter out specific cows. My only suggestion to the UI is that you move the add cow to the center of the screen instead of it being off to the side. Since adding a cow marker is such an integral part of the app, it should be more emphasized and placed in the center so more attention is drawn to it
Team A9
John
I like the app and it is looking really good. I wish the "drop cow" and "remove cow" were closer to the left of the screen or the bottom. Since they are on the far right, it is not as obvious that they are present. I wish the filter had the matching icon of the cow next to it for clarity. Finally, it'd be cool to have a slightly stylized map in the background.
Xu
I really like all of the improvements. The only thing is I feel like the delete button shouldn't always appear on the right side. I think "drop cow" button should always be there, because people might want to drop a cow at anytime. However people would only want to delete something when they choose a cow? So I think it should be when people choose a cow (always create some interactions to indicate users that they have chosen the cow) and then the delete button shows up!