search

pietervdvn / MapComplete

An easy-to-use webapp to edit OpenStreetMap
https://mapcomplete.org
228 stars 92 forks source link

More informations on cameras #1982

Open valerie-garoux opened 5 months ago

valerie-garoux commented 5 months ago

Hello !

I’m using MapComplete to add advertising and cameras on OpenStreetMap sometimes. I already asked you to add an option for poster boxes on transport shelters, and you did great ! Now I have another request, because I share your tool with some of my contacts, to add data, but there’s a lack of fields to add all data needed.

For example, on that node, there is all the necessary information, plus more info. One of the most important is the "operator:type", cause that is very useful after to extract data and see if the camera is in use by a public or a private operator.

Is it possible for you to add some (or all, it would be perfect) of the fields on this particular node ?

Thanks a lot again for your work ! You are useful all around the globe for so much usecases 🙏

danieldegroot2 commented 5 months ago

Summary of surveillance:type=camera

Key # Use # Users # Projects Notes
✔️ man_made=surveillance 200k N/A 17 -
✅ surveillance:type=camera 180k - 5 -
✅ surveillance 160k 11k 6 -
✅ camera:type 150k 8k 5 -
✅ camera:mount 140k 8k 4 Some mappers use support (2k), location (200)
✅ surveillance:zone 90k 7k 4 -
✅ camera:direction 70k 5k 5 Horizontal direction. Some mappers use direction (2k).
✅ operator 30k N/A N/A Custom list or user-defined input only (Could use NSI if not yet).
🟦 height 20k N/A N/A Not supported by any theme
🟦 check_date 15k N/A N/A Other themes. See also survey:date
🟦 camera:angle 10k 1k 2 Vertical direction, similar to roof:angle, incline. Mainly used in central Europe.
☑️ name 8k N/A N/A (Could use NSI if not yet)
🟦 contact:webcam 5k 900 4 Some mappers use website (2k), url (200), url:webcam (30)
🟦 ref 4k N/A N/A Other themes
☑️ operator:type 3k N/A N/A (Could use NSI if not yet). Other themes.
✅ level 3k N/A N/A -
🟦 surveillance:signed 2k 80 None Is it signed: Yes / No ? Mainly used in France, Belgium, Germany (Stuttgart only)
🟦 manufacturer 1k N/A N/A Not supported by any theme. Not used by NSI.
☑️ operator:wikidata 1k N/A N/A (Could use NSI if not yet)
🟦 colour 1k N/A N/A -
✅ indoor 300 N/A N/A surveillance:type=public only
🟦 lit 200 N/A N/A -
--- --- --- --- ---
valerie-garoux commented 5 months ago

I am sorry, but, I am not sure to understand what you mean by "NSI". I don’t this acronym sorry. The "operator:type" key is, I think, the most useful one in your table. It’s really useful to see if this is a public or a private operator, which is very relevant.

danieldegroot2 commented 5 months ago

FYI, NSI refers to name-suggestion-index. Initial support was added in https://github.com/pietervdvn/MapComplete/pull/1934 . See also Contributing to NSI and notability required.

valerie-garoux commented 5 months ago

Thanks for your answer. I am not sure about what to do with this table, but thanks still !