search

pik-piam / remind2

The remind2 package contains the REMIND-specific routines for data and model output manipulation.
0 stars 41 forks source link

Emi|GHG|ESR and Emi|GHG|++|Outside ETS and ESR reporting mismatch #445

Closed 0UmfHxcvx5J7JoaOhFSs5mncnisTJJ6q closed 7 months ago

0UmfHxcvx5J7JoaOhFSs5mncnisTJJ6q commented 1 year ago

The newly implemented summation checks show a mismatch between Emi|GHG|++|ESR and its Emi|GHG|ESR|+|x components, as well as Emi|GHG|++|Outside ETS and ESR and its Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|x components for the indu_subsectors-buil_simple-tran_edge_esm-POP_pop_SSP2EU-GDP_gdp_SSP2EU-En_gdp_SSP2EU-Kap_debt_limit-Reg_62eff8f7.gdx (probably others, too).

Emi|GHG|++|ESR <                                                               <
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Industry                                                      + 
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Transport                                                     + 
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Buildings                                                     + 
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Agriculture                                                   + 
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Waste                                                         + 
Relative difference between -1.4% and -1%, absolute difference up to 11.29 Mt CO2eq/yr.
Emi|GHG|++|Outside ETS and ESR >                                               >
   + Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|Transport                                     + 
   + Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|Land-Use Change                               + 
   + Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|F-Gases                                       + 
Relative difference between -186.4% and 48.2%, absolute difference up to 29.38 Mt CO2eq/yr.
orichters commented 1 year ago

Note: Because of this error in checkSummations, the summation that is claimed to fail above need not be the one that actually failed. Let us maybe sort that out first.

orichters commented 1 year ago

After fixing the error in checkSummations, the error persists (using indu_subsectors-buil_simple-tran_edge_esm-POP_pop_SSP2EU-GDP_gdp_SSP2EU-En_gdp_SSP2EU-Kap_debt_limit-Reg_62eff8f7.gdx):

Emi|GHG|++|ESR <>
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Industry
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Transport
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Buildings
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Agriculture
   + Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Waste
Relative difference between -1.43% and 0.048%, absolute difference up to 31.81 Mt CO2eq/yr.

Emi|GHG|++|Outside ETS and ESR <>
   + Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|Transport
   + Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|Land-Use Change
   + Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|F-Gases
Relative difference between -186.43% and 48.21%, absolute difference up to 31.81 Mt CO2eq/yr.
LaviniaBaumstark commented 7 months ago

what is teh status of this issue? Will it be fixed for REMIND v3.3.0 release?

fschreyer commented 7 months ago

Yes, it should be fixed by this PR. Let's close this once we inspect the new validation runs for summation issues.

orichters commented 7 months ago

/p/projects/remind/modeltests/remind/output/default-AMT_2024-03-15_22.05.00 does not show this mismatch anymore. Thanks for fixing it!