mellamoSimon
commented
7 months ago hi,
the changes were successful in getting rid of most of the inconsistencies. The remaining differences do not seem to step from this part of the code. I suggest merging this to get the reporting back to life and then opening an issue to improve the reporting. I'm running buildLibrary now.
This is a summary of the summation checks after the modifications in this PR:
### Analyzing provided data.
# Use extractVariableGroups to check if summation groups add up.
# Analyzing results of model REMIND
variable groups found in extractVariableGroups
Carbon Management|Carbon Capture >
+ Carbon Management|Carbon Capture|+|Biomass|Pe2Se
+ Carbon Management|Carbon Capture|+|Fossil|Pe2Se
+ Carbon Management|Carbon Capture|+|Industry Energy
+ Carbon Management|Carbon Capture|+|Industry Process
+ Carbon Management|Carbon Capture|+|DAC
Relative difference between 0.0000000311% and 28.8%, absolute difference up to 0.395 Mt CO2/yr.
Carbon Management|Storage >
+ Carbon Management|Storage|+|Biomass|Pe2Se
+ Carbon Management|Storage|+|Fossil|Pe2Se
+ Carbon Management|Storage|+|Industry Energy
+ Carbon Management|Storage|+|Industry Process
+ Carbon Management|Storage|+|DAC
Relative difference between 0.00000059% and 28.8%, absolute difference up to 0.339 Mt CO2/yr.
Emi|CO2|+|Energy >
+ Emi|CO2|Energy|+|Supply
+ Emi|CO2|Energy|+|Demand
+ Emi|CO2|Energy|+|Waste
Relative difference between 0.000000016% and 0.00415%, absolute difference up to 0.301 Mt CO2/yr.
Emi|CO2|Gross|Energy >
+ Emi|CO2|Gross|Energy|+|Supply
+ Emi|CO2|Gross|Energy|+|Demand
+ Emi|CO2|Gross|Energy|+|Waste
Relative difference between 0.0000000159% and 0.00414%, absolute difference up to 0.301 Mt CO2/yr.
Emi|GHG|++|ESR <>
+ Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Industry
+ Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Transport
+ Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Buildings
+ Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Agriculture
+ Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Energy Waste
+ Emi|GHG|ESR|+|Waste
Relative difference between -1.4% and 0.0361%, absolute difference up to 31.8 Mt CO2eq/yr.
Emi|GHG|++|ETS >
+ Emi|GHG|ETS|+|Energy Supply
+ Emi|GHG|ETS|+|Industry
+ Emi|GHG|ETS|+|Transport
+ Emi|GHG|ETS|+|non-BECCS CDR
+ Emi|GHG|ETS|+|Extraction
+ Emi|GHG|ETS|+|Energy Waste
+ Emi|GHG|ETS|+|Waste
Relative difference between 0.0000000194% and 0.00729%, absolute difference up to 0.301 Mt CO2eq/yr.
Emi|GHG|++|Outside ETS and ESR <>
+ Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|Transport
+ Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|Land-Use Change
+ Emi|GHG|Outside ETS and ESR|+|F-Gases
Relative difference between -15519% and 14.8%, absolute difference up to 31.8 Mt CO2eq/yr.
Emi|GHG|+++|Energy >
+ Emi|GHG|Energy|+|Supply
+ Emi|GHG|Energy|+|Demand
+ Emi|GHG|Energy|+|Waste
Relative difference between 0.0000000152% and 0.00375%, absolute difference up to 0.301 Mt CO2eq/yr.
Emi|GHG|Gross|Energy >
+ Emi|GHG|Gross|Energy|+|Supply
+ Emi|GHG|Gross|Energy|+|Demand
+ Emi|GHG|Gross|Energy|+|Waste
Relative difference between 0.0000000152% and 0.00374%, absolute difference up to 0.301 Mt CO2eq/yr.
# Summary of summation group checks for model REMIND:
# 9 equations are not satisfied but should according to extractVariableGroups.
# All deviations can be found in the returned object.
# To get more detailed information on 'Carbon Management|Carbon Capture', run piamInterfaces::variableInfo('Carbon Management|Carbon Capture').
# As generatePlots=FALSE, no plot comparison was produced.
The filtered data contains 84 variables.
### Analyzing provided data.
# Use C:/Users/simonlei/Nextcloud/Documents/Models/local-remind2/remind2/inst/extdata/additional_summation_checks.csv to check if summation groups add up.
# Analyzing results of model REMIND
variable groups found in additional_summation_checks.csv
Emi|CO2 >
+ Emi|CO2|Gross|Energy|Supply|+|Electricity
+ Emi|CO2|Gross|Energy|Supply|Non-electric
+ Emi|CO2|Energy|Demand|+|Transport
+ Emi|CO2|Gross|Energy|Demand|+|Industry
+ Emi|CO2|Energy|Demand|+|Buildings
+ Emi|CO2|Energy|Demand|+|CDR
+ Emi|CO2|+|Land-Use Change
+ Emi|CO2|+|Industrial Processes
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|BECCS
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|Industry CCS|Synthetic Fuels
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|DACCS
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|EW
+ Emi|CO2|Gross|Energy|+|Waste
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|Materials|+|Plastics
Relative difference between 0.0000000133% and 0.00388%, absolute difference up to 0.301 Mt CO2/yr.
Emi|CO2|Cumulated >
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Land-Use Change
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Industrial Processes
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Energy|Demand|Transport
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Gross|Energy|Demand|Industry
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Energy|Demand|Buildings
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Energy|Demand|CDR
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Gross|Energy|Supply|Non-electric
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Gross|Energy|Supply|Electricity
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|Gross|Energy|Waste
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|CDR|BECCS
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|CDR|Industry CCS|Synthetic Fuels
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|CDR|DACCS
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|CDR|EW
+ Emi|CO2|Cumulated|CDR|Materials|Plastics
Relative difference between 0.0000000126% and 0.000767%, absolute difference up to 4.38 Mt CO2.
Emi|GHG >
+ Emi|GHG|Gross|Energy|Supply|Electricity
+ Emi|GHG|Gross|Energy|Supply|Non-electric
+ Emi|GHG|Energy|Demand|+|Buildings
+ Emi|GHG|Gross|Energy|Demand|+|Industry
+ Emi|GHG|Energy|Demand|+|Transport
+ Emi|GHG|Energy|Demand|+|CDR
+ Emi|GHG|Gross|Energy|+|Waste
+ Emi|GHG|+++|Industrial Processes
+ Emi|GHG|+++|Waste
+ Emi|GHG|+++|Agriculture
+ Emi|GHG|+++|Land-Use Change
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|BECCS
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|DACCS
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|Industry CCS|Synthetic Fuels
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|EW
+ Emi|CO2|CDR|Materials|+|Plastics
Relative difference between 0.0000000105% and 0.00239%, absolute difference up to 0.301 Mt CO2eq/yr.
# Summary of summation group checks for model REMIND:
# 3 equations are not satisfied but should according to additional_summation_checks.csv.
# All deviations can be found in the returned object.
# To get more detailed information on 'Emi|CO2', run piamInterfaces::variableInfo('Emi|CO2').
orichters
fschreyer
katarkow
robertpietzcker
0UmfHxcvx5J7JoaOhFSs5mncnisTJJ6q
Fix errors in summations in emissions reporting from feedstock accounting. Some mismatches remain but they will be addressed in other PR (see below).