search

pinterf / xy-VSFilter

xy-VSFilter
GNU General Public License v2.0
558 stars 22 forks source link

Sub/Idx subtitle not correctly positioned #3

Open MonoS opened 6 years ago

MonoS commented 6 years ago

Using the latest version on XySubFilter alongside the latest version of MPC-BE and madVR some subtitle are not correctly displayed appearing some pixel below where they should be (or maybe they are bottom aligned) This does not happen on VLC or using the internal subtitle renderer of MPC-BE Here the screenshot of the problem XySubFilter xy VLC vlc Internal internal Here a test clip test_sub.zip

pinterf commented 6 years ago

Thanks for the report, and just for feedback: I don't think I have the knowledge for solving this problem, since I never had to dig into the background of subtitles. Understanding and reverse engineering how it works probably does not fit into my current schedule, anyway I have saved this issue for myself.

MonoS commented 6 years ago

Do you suggest to open an issue also on the main repo or on the doom9 page? As far as i can see they seems both dead :(

pinterf commented 6 years ago

Ok, tried the 3.1.0.800 version of XySubFilter in MPC-HC BE (x64, v1.5.2 build 3788) and it renders correctly. Downloaded MPC-HC BE From install package x64: Install_XySubFilter.bat (admin rights) MPC-HC: Options/Add Filter/(XySubFilter) Options/Subtitles/Subtitle Renderer: choose XySubFilter

MonoS commented 6 years ago

I have the latest version of both software as you can see. image image

Probably i have some faulty configuration somewhere else?

pinterf commented 6 years ago

Well, madVR was not involved in my setup, not yet figured out (no time) how to do it. Does it happen w/o madVR?

MonoS commented 6 years ago

Tried just now with EVR (Custom) and subtitles are displayed correctly

LazyBumHorse commented 5 years ago

Had a similar problem with XySubFilter (3.1.0.752) and madVR for quite some time, but only on a very small sample of videos. The fix was to go to the madVR settings, processing -> zoom control and disabling 'move subtitles'. By default the option is set to move subtitles to the bottom of the screen/window and for some weird reason this could misplace subtitles even when it's a 720p video being perfectly upscaled to fullscreen 1080p. This didn't happen if the very first ASS line had a /pos tag. I guess the option is useful for moving SRT subtitles below the video (into a black border), but for ASS it can mess things up, so better disable it (or maybe set it to 'move into active video area', but I'm not sure if that works).

MonoS commented 5 years ago

Thanks @LazyBumHorse that seems to be the case, thank you :) .