pioneerspacesim / pioneer

A game of lonely space adventure
https://pioneerspacesim.net
1.63k stars 376 forks source link

Autopilot much slower than expected #5548

Open DynV opened 1 year ago

DynV commented 1 year ago

Observed behaviour

As I was finished my scanning of an ~750Km r asteroid I had trouble with my auto-pilot being set on my next target, a ~500Km r asteroid, my ship moved erratically. I moved manually toward my target ~1 min then set my auto-pilot again, it was bobbing somewhat hard toward my target then the direction became stable but the speed was clearly less than what I expect it would be for such a trip. I moved further from the origin then made the attached save.

Setting the auto-pilot on the target again get stuck at a speed considerably lower than what I expect. It seems to hover very close to 1Km/s from the origin (the gray target, the strongest gravitation) and the relatively slow speed toward the target slowly drop; ~3Km/s while I need to go all the way to 72Km/s to reach a green bar (on the right). I have a feeling the auto-pilot tethers my ship to the origin and I'm going toward my target the most the tether allow.

Expected behaviour

Have a speed toward the target the fastest it can until it reaches ~3/4 of what I'd get from a green bar (on the right).

Steps to reproduce

  1. Load attached gamesave
  2. turn on autopilot to low orbit of the target already set
  3. pay attention to the speed of the origin (in grey on the left).

My pioneer version (and OS): 20230203-win

The attached file was simply renamed so it would go through the upload extension filter, there was no modification to the file content of my save-file. Pioneer-Yoan_Faure-20230203-autopilot_tethered_on_Rhea.zip

Web-eWorks commented 1 year ago

CC @azieba for general autopilot issues (may be an issue with targeting a faraway body with high orbit speed).

DynV commented 1 year ago

Another time but unfortunately my start was over the horizon so my speed is away from the target (but still very close to 1Km/s from the origin). The target wasn't set for this gamesave, it's either of the pending scans, both orbiting Uranus. Pioneer-Yoan_Faure-20230311-autopilot_tethered_on_Phoebe.zip

azieba commented 1 year ago

@DynV I'm having trouble loading your save files in version 20230203. Are you sure this is your version?

Fatal: [T] libs/CargoManager.lua:64: attempt to index field '?' (a nil value)

bszlrd commented 1 year ago

I also had that problem with the save. Do you have any mods active?

Gliese852 commented 1 year ago

Indeed, it does not load, although the save version is 89 (introduced in latest release)

DynV commented 1 year ago

See for yourselves:

C:\Users[user name]>dir %UserProfile%\OneDrive\Documents\Pioneer\mods Volume in drive C has no label. Volume Serial Number is F848-5889

Directory of C:\Users[user name]\OneDrive\Documents\Pioneer\mods

02/12/2023 04:09 PM

. 02/12/2023 04:09 PM .. 0 File(s) 0 bytes 2 Dir(s) 24,536,346,624 bytes free

screenshot-20230218-145316

mkochgdn3810 commented 6 months ago

There are a couple more issues with Rhea. I do not have a proof they 100% related to the original reported issue, but I believe so, so here a some saves and footage of them. Is you interested in only save file and footage directly related to this issue - take a look at the attachments with name 3_SlowSpeed_241c3194b_Manjaro. I have a 1920x1080 footage as well, but it weights too much for GitHub.

README.md

https://github.com/pioneerspacesim/pioneer/assets/106257000/01bcb1dd-c0dd-497b-b216-4ca10e3082e9

4_RheaArtifactsMore_241c3194b_Manjaro.zip

https://github.com/pioneerspacesim/pioneer/assets/106257000/562dc75f-40a6-4560-9392-fb3a70571ddc

4_RheaArtifacts_241c3194b_Manjaro.zip

https://github.com/pioneerspacesim/pioneer/assets/106257000/2e8ae705-1d09-479e-8897-dd731110d162

3_SlowSpeed_241c3194b_Manjaro.zip

https://github.com/pioneerspacesim/pioneer/assets/106257000/2371df03-f589-418c-8c17-b17f81d7585d

https://github.com/pioneerspacesim/pioneer/assets/106257000/1246a0a7-5ccd-49ff-ab4f-c60646492595

https://github.com/pioneerspacesim/pioneer/assets/106257000/47d4bfd8-3697-4d9d-bb8c-7e1fb44331a0

2_RegainControls_241c3194b_Manjaro.zip 1_ToRhea_241c3194b_Manjaro.zip

https://github.com/pioneerspacesim/pioneer/assets/106257000/a3302c82-4ab9-4d3c-8e41-a0e556109bc8