search

pithos / pithos

A Pandora Radio Client
https://pithos.github.io
GNU General Public License v3.0
508 stars 162 forks source link

Notification tray plugin doesn't remember window position when hiding / showing #339

Open JSkier21 opened 8 years ago

JSkier21 commented 8 years ago

I noticed that when I click the pithos icon (Mate 1.12) the window always pops up in the upper left corner, regardless of where it was before hiding it. To make things consistent, I would recommend the notification plugin remembering the window position when hidden, and setting that when showing the pithos app.

I was able to reproduce this in Ubuntu and ArchLinux. Pithos 1.2.1 (both distros); Arch GTK3.20, Ubuntu GTK3.18.

TingPing commented 8 years ago

Currently the plugin simply toggles visibility on the window. My window manager (Gnome3/Mutter) does as seems logical and doesn't move the window. We could manually move it ourselves everytime but I'm not sure I wouldn't blame the WM.

JSkier21 commented 8 years ago

@TingPing, so likely a Mate / Marco issue? I haven't tried Gnome / Mutter myself, but I'll take your word for it.

TingPing commented 8 years ago

Well I'm not against us manually moving the window but I'd certainly like more information on why some WM don't require it and some do.

JSkier21 commented 7 years ago

Seems in xfce too. EDIT: It works fine in xfce, I should be more clear. Mate 1.18 is still an issue.

VLC has a status icon you can minimize and restore (pos remembered), and it's not an issue with that.