search

pl-wnifc / humdrum-polish-scores

Humdrum digital scores from sources in Polish libraries.
https://polishscores.org
Other
7 stars 0 forks source link

pl-cz--ii-153--001-005.krn rhythm problem #1

Open craigsapp opened 9 months ago

craigsapp commented 9 months ago

Score https://verovio.humdrum.org/?file=https%3A%2F%2Fhumdrum.nifc.pl%2Fpl-cz--ii-153--001-005.krn

has a rhythm error on line 1816, m150, where one of the notes in the grace note line is a triplet 16th (that note should probably be converted to a grace note). The problem is in the first violin part (24aa-):

Screenshot 2024-01-31 at 18 43 44
craigsapp commented 9 months ago

The problem is that the LO:SIC is in the wrong column:

Screenshot 2024-02-02 at 21 42 38

Although there is a problem still displaying the regular 24th note as a grace note. It will probably need a layout command where the note is encoded with q but is displayed at regular size.

craigsapp commented 9 months ago

Related problem with https://verovio.humdrum.org/?file=https%3A%2F%2Fhumdrum.nifc.pl%2Fpl-kk--kk-i-8--010.krn

Screenshot 2024-02-08 at 01 11 15

https://polishscores.org/?id=pl-kk--kk-i-8--010

The problem is that there is a note that is 4 or 8. When it is 8, there should be an invisible rest, and when 4, that rest should be replaced with .. In other words, there must be a complete rhythmic syntax in both modern and original. For some reason SIC:o is used, when it should probably be SIC:s (i.e. the original is encoded in the SIC parameter, but it should be storing the correction instead. Or what I really mean is that to o parameter in the SIC should be renamed to s.

jacekiwaszko1 commented 9 months ago

Score https://verovio.humdrum.org/?file=https%3A%2F%2Fhumdrum.nifc.pl%2Fpl-cz--ii-153--001-005.krn

has a rhythm error on line 1816, m150, where one of the notes in the grace note line is a triplet 16th (that note should probably be converted to a grace note). The problem is in the first violin part (24aa-):

It turned out that the SIC comment should be added not to the grace note but to the following one. I moved SIC and added missing information about the beam start to the diplomatic version (gitea). Should I change the encoding here too, or will it be updated automatically?

jacekiwaszko1 commented 9 months ago

Related problem with https://verovio.humdrum.org/?file=https%3A%2F%2Fhumdrum.nifc.pl%2Fpl-kk--kk-i-8--010.krn

Here as well it was a mistake in SIC encoding - there should be no change of the rhythm, so each SIC note should be encoded as 8. I fixed the encoding in the diplomatic score.

For some reason SIC:o is used, when it should probably be SIC:s (i.e. the original is encoded in the SIC parameter, but it should be storing the correction instead. Or what I really mean is that to o parameter in the SIC should be renamed to s.

I think we decided to run all the files through the sic -s filter before the publication of the data. That's why LO:SIC:o= is used there.

craigsapp commented 9 months ago

Should I change the encoding here too, or will it be updated automatically

No need to make changes here as they will be updated the next time I publish all of the score (I check new scores for basic problems and then copy all of the files to this repository).

craigsapp commented 9 months ago

I think we decided to run all the files through the sic -s filter before the publication of the data. That's why LO:SIC:o= is used there.

Yes, I am vaguely remembering 😉 I think the copying process currently does not convert them, so I will add it.