search

plazi / Biodiversity-Literature-Repository

covers the creating, maintenance and upload to the BLR
3 stars 0 forks source link

broken images #40

Open myrmoteras opened 6 years ago

myrmoteras commented 6 years ago

this article has broken images, that is the broken images have been replaced, but the old ones are still online. I know went through all of them and made them close access. Puneet built a switch in ocellus, so that only open access images are shown

https://ocellus.punkish.org/?q=maratus&page=1 2D43FFBFD51B4871FE65995A9D38C032

myrmoteras commented 6 years ago

@gsautter actually, the figures are all corrected. But the fixed images are still there, and since these are many, we nee to remove them. Any idea how to do this?

gsautter commented 6 years ago

Hard one, I'm afraid ... once we've minted a DOI and published the deposition, Zenodo are all but required by their mission to keep the DOI resolvable ...

What we might do is take broken images out of the public, i.e., change them to closed access, and add an isPreviousVersionOf link pointing to the DOI of the repaired image.

Implementation will most likely involve a script working in several steps:

Should be a small-ish tool that I might get around to implementing and running later this week, hopefully taking the broken images off the (publicly accessible) web before anyone uses them to cast a nasty shadow on our achievements.

myrmoteras commented 6 years ago

these are all deposits with broken images that have been replaced, and which I know changed to close access

10.5281/zenodo.270112 10.5281/zenodo.270113 10.5281/zenodo.270114 10.5281/zenodo.270115 10.5281/zenodo.270116 10.5281/zenodo.270117 10.5281/zenodo.270118 10.5281/zenodo.270119 10.5281/zenodo.270120 10.5281/zenodo.270121 10.5281/zenodo.270122 10.5281/zenodo.270123 10.5281/zenodo.270124 10.5281/zenodo.270125 10.5281/zenodo.270126 10.5281/zenodo.270127 10.5281/zenodo.270128 10.5281/zenodo.270129 10.5281/zenodo.270130 10.5281/zenodo.270131 10.5281/zenodo.270132 10.5281/zenodo.270133 10.5281/zenodo.270134 10.5281/zenodo.270135 10.5281/zenodo.270136 10.5281/zenodo.270137 10.5281/zenodo.270138 10.5281/zenodo.270139 10.5281/zenodo.270140 10.5281/zenodo.270141 10.5281/zenodo.270142 10.5281/zenodo.270143 10.5281/zenodo.270144 10.5281/zenodo.270145 10.5281/zenodo.270146 10.5281/zenodo.270147 10.5281/zenodo.270148 10.5281/zenodo.270149 10.5281/zenodo.270150 10.5281/zenodo.270151 10.5281/zenodo.270152 10.5281/zenodo.270153 10.5281/zenodo.270154 10.5281/zenodo.270155 10.5281/zenodo.270156 10.5281/zenodo.270157 10.5281/zenodo.270158 10.5281/zenodo.270159 10.5281/zenodo.270160 10.5281/zenodo.270161 10.5281/zenodo.270162 10.5281/zenodo.270163 10.5281/zenodo.270164 10.5281/zenodo.270165 10.5281/zenodo.270166 10.5281/zenodo.270167 10.5281/zenodo.270168 10.5281/zenodo.270169 10.5281/zenodo.270170 10.5281/zenodo.270171 10.5281/zenodo.270172 10.5281/zenodo.270173 10.5281/zenodo.270174 10.5281/zenodo.270175 10.5281/zenodo.270176 10.5281/zenodo.270177 10.5281/zenodo.270178 10.5281/zenodo.270179 10.5281/zenodo.270180 10.5281/zenodo.270181 10.5281/zenodo.270182 10.5281/zenodo.270183 10.5281/zenodo.270184 10.5281/zenodo.270185 10.5281/zenodo.270186 10.5281/zenodo.270187 10.5281/zenodo.270188 10.5281/zenodo.270189 10.5281/zenodo.270190 10.5281/zenodo.270191 10.5281/zenodo.270192 10.5281/zenodo.270193 10.5281/zenodo.270194 10.5281/zenodo.270195 10.5281/zenodo.270196 10.5281/zenodo.270197 10.5281/zenodo.270198 10.5281/zenodo.270199 10.5281/zenodo.270200 10.5281/zenodo.270201 10.5281/zenodo.270202 10.5281/zenodo.270203 10.5281/zenodo.270204 10.5281/zenodo.270205 10.5281/zenodo.270206 10.5281/zenodo.270207 10.5281/zenodo.270208 10.5281/zenodo.270209 10.5281/zenodo.270210 10.5281/zenodo.270211

myrmoteras commented 6 years ago

ok - before I read your comment, I started to change the images to closed acccess. If you can make a script that is even better with the inclusion to the fixed image

there has been a comment on Twitter - but if we act quickly, this is in a sense not bad because it allows us to show that we are responsive, and that is a good sign today. The only bad thing would be if we keep producing more broken images - which we don't right now

gsautter commented 6 years ago

And maybe it might even end up proving some nasty person an envious liar to a good few people ...

myrmoteras commented 6 years ago

I am not worried about this

gsautter commented 6 years ago

As to the source of the broken images: That was due to re-use of existing third-party software (don't you re-invent the wheel, etc.) ... once we found out about these broken images, I investigated closer and found that thing to be outright naively implemented. And then went on to make a wheel that is round rather then triangular.

Bottom line: the problem has long been resolved, but we have some data pollution remaining to clean up.

gsautter commented 6 years ago

This is proving a hard one ... the API will only ever give me the first 10,000 results for whichever query I submit, and there seems to be no way of listing depositions that have an isPartOf relationship with a given DOI.

Hope Lars will be able to shed some light.