Content: Go through migrated content and check for issues

rioksane commented 1 year ago

After migration, go through migrated content and check for problems. Write issues down here.

Since we create new pages for most main sections, old main pages can be hidden.

If you notice CSS-related problems, create new issues of those.

mpeeters commented 1 year ago

[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/copyright-licensing-logo/policy : error on volto view (fix manually, cause: https://github.com/plone/blocks-conversion-tool/issues/15)
[ ] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/event-sponsorship/eventsponsorshipdetails & https://beta.plone.org/foundation/event-sponsorship/marketingeventsponsorshipdetails : links are broken. The external llinks already only have href="event-sponsorship-request" I guess they will work again after the urls are switched
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/event-sponsorship/plone-event-sponsorship-policy : error on volto view and some links are broken
[ ] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/event-sponsorship/plone-event-sponsorship-policy-oldversion : broken links
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/governance-process/governance-process : last link plone.org/community is broken (resolveuid)
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/donors/donors : error on volto view. Same as first: anchor in "The Fine Print" -> fix manually
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/donors/sponsorship : error on volto view. Same as first: anchor in a heading -> fix manually
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/materials/privacy : This page does not exist
[ ] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/materials/archive : by clicking on the first or second link the backend have an issue (recursive), example of url : https://beta.plone.org/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/++api++/foundation/materials/archive/Plone%20Bylaws%20Final%20-%20Amended%202004-05-10.DOC
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2004 : This page does not exist
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2005/membermtg2005 : missing content -> https://plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2005/membermtg2005
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2006/nominations/aaron-vanderlip https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2006/nominations/andy-mckay https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2006/nominations/david-siedband https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2006/nominations/fabio-rizzo-matos https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2006/nominations/geir-bekholt and more on the same folder: This page does not exist
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2009-membership-meeting/nominations/spanky : error on volto view
[ ] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/membership/2018-membership-meeting/nominations/carol-ganz : this page does not exist
[ ] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/sponsorship : broken links : [organizing and attending strategic sprints, conferences and marketing events](https://beta.plone.org/resolveuid/fb74b9a5fd4d4d90a43a798da160f577), [Become a Premium Sponsor](https://beta.plone.org/foundation/sponsorship-form?type-of-sponsorship=Premium), [Become a Standard Sponsor](https://beta.plone.org/foundation/sponsorship-form?type-of-sponsorship=Standard), [Become a University Sponsor](https://beta.plone.org/foundation/sponsorship-form?type-of-sponsorship=University), [Become a Foundation Hero](https://beta.plone.org/foundation/be-a-hero)
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/about/historical-newsitems/conservancy-vote-results : this page does not exist
[x] https://plone.org/foundation/about/historical-newsitems/2004_board : empty content
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/about/historical-newsitems/announcement : empty content
[x] https://plone.org/foundation/meetings/minutes/2004/minutes-20041216 : empty content
[x] https://beta.plone.org/foundation/meetings/minutes/2007/minutes-april-5th-2007 : This page does not exist
[x] https://plone.org/foundation/meetings/minutes/2009/agenda-may-28-2009 : empty content
[x] https://plone.org/foundation/meetings/agendas/2004/agenda-20041203 : empty content and link was imported - See https://github.com/plone/blocks-conversion-tool/issues/16

rioksane commented 1 year ago

[x] Plone open garden (1 single special page) https://beta.plone.org/plone-open-garden is empty -> no need to fix, we just create a new one. --> https://github.com/plone/plone.org/issues/36 Not blocker for plone.org release
[x] Migrated pages do not contain Breadcrumbs? https://beta.plone.org/community/conference --> This will fix it: https://github.com/plone/plone.org/pull/38
[x] Error https://beta.plone.org/foundation/copyright-licensing-logo/policy

rioksane commented 1 year ago

[x] Hotfixes are missing title https://beta.plone.org/security/hotfix/20220128 (compare to https://plone.org/security/hotfix/20220128)
[x] Release are missing titles https://beta.plone.org/download/releases/6.0.0rc1 - well, the same problem in the original https://plone.org/download/releases/6.0.0rc1

fredvd commented 1 year ago

[ ] The Plone newsroom https://beta.plone.org/newsroom/the-plone-newsroom . The blocks conversion tools interprets/converts inline span elements to paragraphs, so a single paragraph in rich text becomes 4 in converted page.

So this paragraph on the top of the page:

<img src="https://plone.org/newsroom/images/tpn-official-landscape.png/@@images/b1db07e5-0ad1-4133-b005-e9c15af1be47.png" title="TPN-official-landscape.png" alt="TPN-official-landscape.png" class="image-right">A monthly podcast about Plone, the Plone community and whatever we come up with to keep you informed. We will do our best to release a new recording  at the beginning of every month.

Gets converted to:

<p>A monthly podcast about Plone, the Plone community and whatever we come up with to keep you informed. We will do our best to release a new recording&nbsp;</p>
<p> at the beginning of</p>
<p> every month.</p>

[x] default pages content is not hoisted up one level to be the blocks content of the folder

rioksane commented 1 year ago

[x] https://beta.plone.org/related-websites//contents is empty vs. https://plone.org/related-websites/ BUT its probably redundant on the new site since that section is only used on on of the old sites frontpage block Its was a unmigrated custom content-type "Site link"

fredvd commented 1 year ago

https://beta.plone.org/community/admin-and-infrastructure/admin-and-infrastructure

The Volto slate edior and/or the theme handle whitespace differently than the html based layout. It's maybe not a migration isssue if it can be fixed in the theme:

[ ] Empty  show up in the blocks editors as new lines, when they are removed/hidden in the view by html,but this is slate creating a block element in the editor

edit mode empty strongs are shown as newlines

[ ] Check the spacing in the membership list for the 3 last members: between Full name and github nickname there is no white space. Newlines are not considered as inline space in Volto. The underlying html is exactly the same though:

fredvd commented 1 year ago

[ ] Another probably theming issue: Margin between <ul> and  containers is collapsed in Volto but has the correct spacing in html. The html code is the same. This happens only in view, in the Volto block editor there is the correct vertical margin.

pbauer commented 1 year ago

At least the following items have no or broken or incomplete text due to the issues in the blocks-conversion-tool:

pbauer commented 1 year ago

related-websites//contents

These were of the custom content-type "Site Link" which we did not migrate. I'd say: recreate it.

pbauer commented 1 year ago

Most issues here are fixed. I suggest we create new tickets for new issues.

rioksane commented 1 year ago

Migrated content seems to run 99% fine. Of any broken stuff there is separate issues. I will close this.

plone / plone.org

Content: Go through migrated content and check for issues #34