search

poehlerj / no-title-bar

Integrates maximized windows with the top panel
https://extensions.gnome.org/extension/2015/no-title-bar-forked/
GNU General Public License v2.0
67 stars 10 forks source link

adds a second titlebar to firefox on ubuntu 20.04 #27

Open bughit opened 3 years ago

bughit commented 3 years ago

image

Firefox by default does not have a system titlebar, but draws its own.

johanricher commented 3 years ago

In the latest version of Firefox, the title bar is removed by default which has the effect or disturbing the normal behaviour of the no-title-bar extension. To get back to the previous situation, the solution I found is to re-enable the Firefox Title Bar in the Customize settings (look in the bottom left corner):

image

bughit commented 3 years ago

The point here is not wasting vertical space, if one didn't mind space wasting redundant title-bars one probably wouldn't be trying this extension.

The solution is to use the pixel saver extension, which also happens to be in the ubuntu repo

https://packages.ubuntu.com/source/focal/gnome-shell-extension-pixelsaver

It does not have this problem.

poehlerj commented 3 years ago

The problem here is the following: Gnome, as have many other display managers, has started to let the applications decide, how it would like to handle its own titlebar, instead of always rendering one for the window. More and more applications have started to do so, like Gnome itself. The Gnome-Terminal or Nautilus have integrated functionality into the titlebar. Mozilla started doing so themselves about 2 years ago by adding the option to hide the titlebar entirely and basically integrating the open tabs into its own titlebar. All this extension does, is to give gnome a hint, that the titlebar can be removed, if it doesn't have any functionality. This doesn't work everytime, because sometimes applications are giving the "wrong" information to the display manager, that they "need" their titlebar and gnome doesn't remove it. One of them seems to be firefox (which I personally fixed by applying the same settings as @johanricher has), but there are many others, like for instance various QT-applications. I hope I could make things clearer here, that there is no unique way of going with the titlebars anymore and there probably will be even less way of enhancing this behaviour through the display manager in the future, up to the point, where this extension becomes useless. Anyway, this still isn't the case right now.

quinndiggity commented 3 years ago

In the latest version of Firefox, the title bar is removed by default which has the effect or disturbing the normal behaviour of the no-title-bar extension. To get back to the previous situation, the solution I found is to re-enable the Firefox Title Bar in the Customize settings (look in the bottom left corner):

image

Thanks for this 👍🏻

quinndiggity commented 3 years ago

@bughit once you begin experiencing complete freezes of gnome-shell 2-5 times a week with pixel-saver, and notice that the menu buttons in the top bar don't actually work: the solution is to use the no-titlebar extension, which hasn't had it's metadata updated to include gnome > 3.30 (https://github.com/franglais125/no-title-bar/blob/master/metadata.json#L13), so "the solution" is to use the no-title-bar-forked extension, which also happens to be in gnome extensions site and github

https://packages.ubuntu.com/source/focal/gnome-shell-extension-pixelsaver https://github.com/poehlerj/no-title-bar

It does not have these problems.