SPF didn't pass in mails

[Manishjodhani]

Hi, I have verfied spf and dkim but when i send the mails and check they pass or not. Dkim is passed but spf none. How to solve this problem?? Received-SPF: none (zoho.com: 101.259.12.282 is neither permitted nor denied by domain of postal.example.com) You can also check the attachments.

[willpower232]

Make sure that the domain names mentioned in your SPF records exist and that one of them relates to the IP address of the server.

(Your screenshot doesn't really hide the domain names you're using so I can tell you that the domain name in your SPF record has no IP address when I use nslookup on it)

[Manishjodhani]

Ok i will provide you my domain and ip pools.

[Manishjodhani]

I using this ip pools ip4:145.239.22.192/27 ip4:54.38.131.224/27 and my postal hostname : rmta.gonode.tech. my sender domain : rccess.tech. Have a look in screenshots. http://prntscr.com/ie1m3t

[Manishjodhani]

please tell me soon sir..???

[willpower232]

The SPF record for rccess.tech links to spf.rmta.gonode.tech

BUT there are currently no records for spf.rmta.gonode.tech so thats probably where you're going wrong.

Make sure you have created all the main records as per https://github.com/atech/postal/wiki/Domains-&-DNS-Configuration

[Manishjodhani]

v=spf1 a mx include:spf.rmta.gonode.tech ~all i have add this record in gonode.tech.....but still not pass the spf. So, please can you this check again.

[willpower232]

spf.rmta.gonode.tech doesn't exist, it needs to exist otherwise your SPF record is pointless

[Manishjodhani]

I have add the record it will take time.I will update you. can you tell me that how can i remove mails id from suppression list.

[Manishjodhani]

I have updated the record but still. Spf did not pass. check the screenshot http://prntscr.com/ie2slr

[willpower232]

spf.rmta.gonode.tech doesn't exist, it needs to exist otherwise your SPF record is pointless

[Manishjodhani]

Please check once again. I have done the update records. And please take a look in screen shot.

[willpower232]

Thats slightly better but the record needs to include your IP addresses, NOT the record.

[Manishjodhani]

please check after the include ip addresses but still no progress, spf did not pass. here my sender domain is hostcot.com and my postal host name is rmta.gonode.tech please check where i was going wrong.

[Manishjodhani]

Please check it ASAP. Please Sir.

[willpower232]

You need to remove include:spf.rma.gonode.tech as it makes no sense when the record has the same name.

[willpower232]

hostcot.com -> "v=spf1 a mx include:spf.rmta.gonode.tech ~all"

spf.rmta.gonode.tech -> "v=spf1 ip4:145.239.22.192/27 ip4:54.38.131.224/27 ~all"

[Manishjodhani]

i have done as you said but still no progress.

[willpower232]

Can you send a screenshot of the SPF error you are receiving?

[Manishjodhani]

Here you can see what i have done

screenshot of my mail box http://i.prntscr.com/bUWSF8PdQDi-fB1UmY-EEw.png

[Manishjodhani]

Can you rectify what are thing i'm missing??

[alexroosenstein]

Make sure you also add a SPF record for rp.rmta.gonode.tech.

[Manishjodhani]

@alexroosenstein

Yes, i try what you said but still no progress

have a look in screenshot

[alexroosenstein]

Could you paste the latest email headers?

[Manishjodhani]

have a look @alexroosenstein .

[alexroosenstein]

My bet is now that there's some sort of cache, try again in an hour or so, it should be resolved then.

[igerzog]

You have a mistake! In some places I see gonode.tech and somewhere - gondoe.tech

[Manishjodhani]

Thanks @igerzog

[willpower232]

That typo came from https://github.com/atech/postal/issues/496#issuecomment-365548588 so just give it some time for gmail to update itself and that should be that.

[willpower232]

Oh wait thats the settings in Postal, can you double check all the gonode's in your Postal and make sure they aren't gondoe's?

[Manishjodhani]

Thanks @willpower232 now it working...:)