search

ppy / osu-stable-issues

Report critical osu-stable issues here
60 stars 11 forks source link

osu!mania special style and MR mod unintentionally mirrors S key #1122

Closed aryoadhi closed 1 year ago

aryoadhi commented 1 year ago

An osu!mania map with special style layout enabled and using special style layout in gameplay will mirror the whole map (including S key) when using Mirror mod.

Screenshot 1: Normal map with left S key (original)

screenshot917

Screenshot 2: Normal map with left S key and Mirror mod

screenshot918

Screenshot 3: Normal map with right S key

screenshot928

Screenshot 4: Normal map with right S key and Mirror mod

screenshot929

Expected result pattern-wise:

WindowsMeosu commented 1 year ago

"An osu!mania map with special style layout enabled and using special style layout in gameplay will mirror the whole map" Pretty sure mirror is meant to mirror the whole map regardless if special style is enabled... right?

aryoadhi commented 1 year ago

That, however, is an unintended result. On games with special key, mirror mod only mirrors non-special lanes order.

aryoadhi commented 1 year ago

I should have look at the existing posts (for some reason Github defaults to open cases). I guess we already concluded with not fixing it on stable as it's already feature-locked.

Read: https://github.com/ppy/osu-stable-issues/issues/912