search

ppy / osu-stable-issues

Report critical osu-stable issues here
61 stars 11 forks source link

Increase the Tag limit of 1000 characters #779

Open dudehacker opened 3 years ago

dudehacker commented 3 years ago

Problem Statement:

The artist is a group of people, without a group name. Imagine AKB48 if they didn't have a group name.

By RC rules, Various Artists is used in artist field then the character names/singer names in both EN/JP is moved to tags field. The result exceeds 1000 when tags also contain other things needed which makes map impossible to upload.

Removing space between English names works for In game searching but not Web searching. This is against RC romanization rules for JP which resulted in my map getting DQ.

So in the end I needed to remove some character name, which is data loss caused by technical issue.

Please increase the tags limit so this doesn't happen again.

I am aware this situation is very rare since usually they would have a group name, but it's still a big problem.

Map where this problem occurred: https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/1418151#mania/2921882

peppy commented 3 years ago

How long did you need the field to be for your particular use case?

dudehacker commented 3 years ago

It is not for me, my map is already ranked with data loss. It's to prevent future problem. I am not sure how much $ it adds to server space by increasing the limit of this. Assuming a group of 30-50 people, 3-5k char limit would be nice imo.

peppy commented 3 years ago

Tags can be changed after a map is ranked. I am asking for your beatmap/use case specifically.

dudehacker commented 3 years ago

The tags I had to drop are: "Machikane Fukukitaru Taiki Shuttle Sakura Bakushin O Air Groove Winning Ticket"

h3oCharles commented 3 years ago

pretty sure monstrata's tribute to kyoani had trouble with 1k char limit wouldn't be surprised with nevo's oral cigarettes song comp also did

T0chi commented 2 years ago

Tags can be changed after a map is ranked. I am asking for your beatmap/use case specifically.

Does this still apply today?

T0chi commented 2 years ago

Regarding this map: https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/1777727#osu/3640549 Tags: https://pastebin.com/TWWk0zXj

peppy commented 2 years ago

The limit is unchanged at 1,000 characters.

The server-side tags for that beatmap are taishi appreciation team wasteland in the depths inside blue inside - part2 the angels distant relatives encounter like a rendezvous (in another world) keys to the disired image (spirit chords mix) tanchiky confide alkome take me project-g choke feryquitous devoed nhato telling the world zekk opal songs compilation electronic instrumental dnb drum and bass dubstep drumstep trance house progressive ambient, if that helps answer your question.