search

ppy / osu-web

the browser-facing portion of osu!
https://osu.ppy.sh
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
969 stars 380 forks source link

Finalized Kudosu/Mapper's Choice Proposal #3978

Open downpour-osu opened 5 years ago

downpour-osu commented 5 years ago

Discussion of the proposal, the problems it tackles, why it's necessary, rounds of community feedback, and changes is available on the forums here: https://osu.ppy.sh/community/forums/topics/811598

I am suggesting a Star Priority box on the beatmap page that mappers may (click?) to donate 5 kudosu at a time to, including the mapper themself, and upon reaching 125 star priority the map's modding page would offer the mapper a button to place the map into the mapper's choice system, which would function nearly identically to loved in adding a leaderboard but not pp, and display as a separate section from ranked. Each map has a 125 kudosu per user limit on donations.

I'm also suggesting a box on the front page to house "Mapper's Choice Gold" which contains the top 5 mapper's choice maps by highest star priority with some sort of decay effect for time since kudosu donated. I also think it should get a special section of osu direct that is easily visible in osu lazer.

downpour-osu commented 4 years ago

This will have been up for a year and a half in 6 days. Given that I am always told that "anyone can contribute and have their ideas discussed, you just need to spearhead it properly" I would love to see ANY sort of response/action related to this.

downpour-osu commented 4 years ago

I'm begging to see some action or discussion or anything about this.

Helen0903 commented 4 years ago

I personally think this is a really cool idea, but you shouldn't expect it to happen any time soon because it's a pretty time intensive idea, and also there are other issues that will be prioritised before any proposal.

It's already been acknowledged and tagged by ppy so I'd just wait or see what you can do/make to work towards implementing your idea.

downpour-osu commented 4 years ago

what can i do towards implementing this then

downpour-osu commented 1 year ago

so it's been another 3 years and I'm still waiting. anyway to ping peppy in this?

downpour-osu commented 1 year ago

it's so simple and so common sense, I don't understand why this has been completely ignored. I've waited 5 years for this to receive attention.

furiner commented 1 year ago

I think adding a sort of mediation middleground between whether a map lands in that category would work very well, because as it stands; currently a category like that would falter under the premise of people brigading terrible and low quality maps into the category, which is generally going to give it a very poor reputation; and make it look nothing better than just having a map be left in pending or the graveyard.

This would ensure a form of quality control, and I'm sure there are people who would be willing to undertake overlooking a queue of this caliber. Beyond that, I do think this would work very well under the current ecosystem of osu! at a whole; but that's not my decision to make.

downpour-osu commented 1 year ago

Would love to see some sort of community led team sort of like loved with experienced mappers responsible for overseeing VERY LIGHT BASIC MODERATION but not really intervening in disputes between mappers