search

ppy / osu

rhythm is just a *click* away!
https://osu.ppy.sh
MIT License
15.32k stars 2.28k forks source link

Song selection not consistent with "now playing" song on startup #25892

Closed ImJustAFish closed 10 months ago

ImJustAFish commented 10 months ago

Type

Crash to desktop

Bug description

Upon entering the song selection screen, one of three things happens: song selection matches "now playing" song selection defaults to lowest difficulty map song selection plays random map

not a big priority but it is a small annoyance to be had.

Screenshots or videos

https://github.com/ppy/osu/assets/66386095/38547cb8-4e52-433a-8b2c-f1137c486bf0

Version

2023.1218.1

Logs

compressed-logs.zip

bdach commented 10 months ago

This is by design.

Main menu doesn't filter beatmaps by ruleset when looking for something to play, but song select does. You have catch ruleset active and converts off, so if the beatmap chosen by the game at the start does not have a catch difficulty, song select will arbitrarily switch to something that fits the active filters.

ImJustAFish commented 10 months ago

This is by design.

Main menu doesn't filter beatmaps by ruleset when looking for something to play, but song select does. You have catch ruleset active and converts off, so if the beatmap chosen by the game at the start does not have a catch difficulty, song select will arbitrarily switch to something that fits the active filters.

ah that makes sense, thanks!

sourajit02 commented 9 months ago

This is by design.

Is there a valid design reason to not have the user-set difficulty/ruleset filters apply for the main menu playlist? It is a bit disappointing to find a nice song on game startup, only to find that it is way outside the star range you have set.

peppy commented 9 months ago

If you see value in this, open a discussion. Depends how many others would like the behaviour to change.