prebid / Prebid.js

Setup and manage header bidding advertising partners without writing code or confusing line items. Prebid.js is open source and free.
https://docs.prebid.org
Apache License 2.0
1.28k stars 2.05k forks source link

exchanges replying with "estimates" or "averages" #12

Closed djlosch closed 9 years ago

djlosch commented 9 years ago

As described in the docs for prebid, and on appnexus, some exchanges don't actually respond with their true bid value. Instead, they reply with estimates, ranges, or averages.

This defeats the entire purpose of header bidding. Mathematically, there's little difference in this from the days of waterfalls and line item averages... but now it's implemented manually instead of letting DFP do the work.

_If an exchange does not respond with their true bid value for that impression, they should not be supported_. Alternatively, is there a chart that shows who responds with true bid values, and who doesn't?

prebid commented 9 years ago

+1. You're right - header bidding without price can be done through a waterfall in DFP. The latter is actually better without having to make the page wait. We're trying to keep track of this as well, as it indeed affects our implementation for different bidders.

For a bidder that responds with exact price and creative, the implementation can be standard. For a bidder that obfuscates the price or not returning one, the line items have to be setup differently. More can be found here:

http://prebid.org/bidders.html

djlosch commented 9 years ago

I get that a standard can exist that says bidders must reply with actual bids, but it's already gotten out that some bidders aren't following that standard. Is there yet a chart or list of who is / isn't replying with true bids? There are a bunch of bidders with adapters that are already coded... do they all reply with true bids? A public list would be awesome because...

prebid commented 9 years ago

Great suggestion and we hope this page would somewhat help: http://prebid.org/blog/header-bidding-bidder-analysis/

It's possible that we don't have the most up to date info from bidders. Some may be developing new APIs that allow real price back. This above analysis is what we've seen publishers are using today.

prebid commented 9 years ago

Closing this for now. Hopefully the analysis page helps.