search

project-chip / matter-handbook

This is the repoository for the Matter Handbook, content is published at https://handbook.buildwithmatter.com
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
11 stars 11 forks source link

Fixes #19 - Added new device types in the 1.3 specification #21

Closed jamesharrow closed 1 month ago

jamesharrow commented 2 months ago

Added new device types in the 1.3 specification (from 0.9 ballot). Note that not sure if Water Freeze Detector and Rain Sensor are supported and certifiable. Needs checking.

ReneJosefsen commented 2 months ago

Given the clusters used by the two mentioned device type did pass SVE, I'm not aware that these should NOT be a part of 1.3?

jamesharrow commented 2 months ago

Given the clusters used by the two mentioned device type did pass SVE, I'm not aware that these should NOT be a part of 1.3?

I assume we are talking about Water Freeze Detector and Rain Sensor.

As you say these use the same underlying cluster (Boolean State) so I'm assuming that they are, but Rob's email for 0.9 ballot didn't explicitly mention them, but did mention Water Leak detector.

ReneJosefsen commented 2 months ago

Given the clusters used by the two mentioned device type did pass SVE, I'm not aware that these should NOT be a part of 1.3?

I assume we are talking about Water Freeze Detector and Rain Sensor.

As you say these use the same underlying cluster (Boolean State) so I'm assuming that they are, but Rob's email for 0.9 ballot didn't explicitly mention them, but did mention Water Leak detector.

I can not speak to the reason for that, but I would assume it is a simple oversight. The main focus was on the leakage detector, the water freeze detector and rain sensor was "bolted on" during the development since they were obvious device types that could easily be constructed using the proposed clusters, so often the water management effort was referred to as just leakage and valve 🤷🏻‍♂️ I'm not sure who can give the final answer here 🤔 @robszewczyk do you have any input here?

FYI: They are all mentioned in the slide deck from the plenary held just before the Singapore AMM as a part of the finalized 0.9 ballot.

Videonisse commented 1 month ago

I assume you have already sorted this out, but anyway, they are in the Device Library spec for v1.3: