search

project-open-data / db-to-api

Turns a Database into a Secure, RESTful API
448 stars 150 forks source link

Zend APIgility #13

Open tailorvj opened 10 years ago

tailorvj commented 10 years ago

Hi, what are your thoughts about Zend's DB to API library apigility? https://github.com/zfcampus/zf-apigility-skeleton

kinlane commented 10 years ago

My personal experience is that Zend does solid tooling around APIs, but for me they make their implementation and framework a little more complex than they need to be. They do what you need, but take more overhead to configure and customize.

tailorvj commented 10 years ago

My experience shows that when a major player such as Zend enters such a field in a reasonable manor, it usually gains much traction. Since they are pledging for community support, I would suggest you take part of their project and that way the entire community may benefit from your experience and knowledge.

Cheers, Tailor

waldoj commented 10 years ago

@tailorvj, IMHO, this is way too difficult for our target demographic—federal agencies for whom the prospect of putting together an API is technologically beyond their capabilities or funding. Zend lost me at this step:

At this point, you need to use Composer to install dependencies. Assuming you already have Composer:

composer.phar install

That's a deal-breaker. Many of the people implementing this within agencies are not able to install software on a server (for reasons of permissions or limited experience) beyond simply uploading a directory via FTP. "Composer" does not appear to be SCAP validated, either, which makes it quite difficult for federal agencies to use it. (This is a process that I have no experience with, though.)

Apigility might be really great, but I don't think it's feasible for Project Open Data's audience.