search

prose-im / prose-app-web

Prose Web application. XMPP client for team messaging.
https://prose.org/downloads
Mozilla Public License 2.0
24 stars 2 forks source link

Separate "Create Channel" and "Join Channel" dialogs #139

Open nesium opened 1 month ago

nesium commented 1 month ago

Moving this into a new ticket to have a discussion about the issue…

Source: https://github.com/prose-im/prose-app-web/issues/136#issuecomment-2299168760

Say I have a private room "abc" on the same server where my account is and want to join it.

I click "Add a channel". Should I enter the full address here even though it's the same server? That would differ from the behavior of joining a public room.

So I enter "abc" and click "Create Channel". The web app now tries to find the room "abc" by calling findPublicChannelByName which fails, since the room is private. It then proceeds to call createPublicChannel which creates a new channel with that name but a different identifier.

nesium commented 1 month ago

This is somewhat related to prose-im/prose-pod-system#4, just to bring this back to our attention.