jesseclay
commented
6 years ago tl;dr: Personally I think fine to stop paying heroku for now. Google interface is ok but not great, so we should figure out a replacement in the not too distant future.
Current version of GAPS has significant security flaws, so decision was made to take GAPS down until those are fixed. I'm not sure if Stripe is using their latest published version or not, but seems unlikely given last update of over a year ago.
Realistically I think GAPS will need a nearly complete re-write to be useful for us. Though this will take time & energy, it may be worth it. To the best of my knowledge the Google UI doesn't solve the following problems that gaps was invented for:
- Easily see all mailing lists & those that are subscribed to, subscribe/un-subscribe with one click
- Easily import filters into gmail so groups are sorted automatically (though gmail oauth & automatic filter importing has always been broken in GAPS, so need to download all the filters & import manually)
At the least we can do the above things in the google ui for now, but if we're going to keep using mailing lists (v. useful imo) then I think we should put the GAPS re-write in the pipeline (or maybe there are other solutions already released? I haven't looked deeply). This seems like a project that would be especially well suited for someone in PL Team or a vendor.
On Thu, Nov 2, 2017 at 10:18 PM, ᴠɪᴄᴛᴏʀ ʙᴊᴇʟᴋʜᴏʟᴍ notifications@github.com wrote:
GAPS application has not been working for quite a while. Google Apps does have a UI for discovering groups already. Currently it seems that we're paying Heroku around $32 a month for hosting the GAPS application and also engineering effort and time for maintaining it. In the end, is it worth it or should we just default to use the UI Google gives us instead?
— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/protocol/gaps/issues/5, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABo90x1yT4huMpYkgIyoR77HYiFSavIFks5syoX4gaJpZM4QQnPg .
dignifiedquire
GAPS application has not been working for quite a while. Google Apps does have a UI for discovering groups already. Currently it seems that we're paying Heroku around $32 a month for hosting the GAPS application and also engineering effort and time for maintaining it. In the end, is it worth it or should we just default to use the UI Google gives us instead?