search

ptvoinfo / zigbee-configurable-firmware

PTVO firmware for CC2530, CC2531, and CC2652 Zigbee chips
https://ptvo.info/zigbee-configurable-firmware-features/
MIT License
205 stars 22 forks source link

Bind command executed after Trigger #235

Open obrain17 opened 1 year ago

obrain17 commented 1 year ago

I have a modified ZBMini with this configuration:

image

Input 2 is linked to Output 2 and has the Bind command "Toggle". For this one it is bound to a device called AmpPlug:

image

This "Toggle" command is executed whenever the Switch on Input 2 is switched - as expected.

Now I found that the Bind command is also executed when Output 2 is set to "off" after a "Trigger" command ('onWithTimedOff') has timed out.

I think state changes on Outputs should not affect Bind commands on Inputs that are linked to them. Normal "on" and "off" and starting the "onWithTimedOff" on do already correctly not affect the Bind command.

Behaviour is for both CC2530 and CC2652.

ptvoinfo commented 1 year ago

@obrain17 This output is linked to an input. So, yes, it can affect the input.

obrain17 commented 1 year ago

I checked with a different setup, with Input not linked to the Output:

image

If the Input 2 is not linked to the Output 2, the behaviour is still the same: The Bind command "Toggle" is sent when Output 2 is set to "off" after a "Trigger" command ('onWithTimedOff') has timed out.

Probably the internal timer callback function additionally executes all binding commands for endpoint 2 rather than just switching the Output off and report this.