replicate firestore not replicating correctly

[marnec]

I can't create a working pull request because this bug requires a firestore database;

I have a minimal Angular test PWA that instantiates a single collection called inbox with Dexiejs

after awaiting creation and migration, I start the firestore replication:

this.rxDatabase = await createRxDatabase<...>(...);
const collections = await this.rxDatabase.addCollections({...});
if (collections.inbox.migrationNeeded()) await collections.inbox.startMigration(10);

const replicationState = replicateFirestore({
    collection: collections.inbox,
    replicationIdentifier: 'inbox',
    autoStart: true,
    live: true,
    pull: {},
    push: {},
    firestore: {
        database: this.firestore,
        collection: collection(this.firestore, 'inbox'),
        projectId: environment.firebase.appId
    },
})

documents in firebase have the serverTimestamp correctly filled, and the serverTimestamp property is not added to RxJsonSchema of the document as per documentation

the replication shows the following behaviours:

• firestore:
  • First-time replication works, existing documents in firestore are pulled, existing documents in local-db are pushed
  • Subsequently, only push operations work (from browser to firestore and from the pwa installed on a phone to firestore), while pull operations don't work
  • If I restart the development environment not even first-time replication works
  • Only by changing the replicationIdentifier property, first-time replication works again once
  • By inspecting the network the replication system is continuosly opening and closing subscription to firestore

• firestore emulator:
  • First-time replication does not work completely, existing documents in local-db are not pushed but existing documents in firestore are pulled correctly
  • Subsequently pull and push operations work correctly
  • The replication system correctly opens a subscription to firestore and keeps it open

I looked online, read the discord and tried many different configuration but I can't get it working

[pubkey]

Shouldnt it be possible to make a PR with a test that shows the failing emulator behavior?

[marnec]

Shouldnt it be possible to make a PR with a test that shows the failing emulator behavior?

Yes I'll try as soon as possible, thanks for the quick reply

[stale[bot]]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed soon. Please update it or it may be closed to keep our repository organized. The best way is to add some more information or make a pull request with a test case. Also you might get help in fixing it at the RxDB Community Chat If you know you will continue working on this, just write any message to the issue (like "ping") to remove the stale tag.

[stale[bot]]

Issues are autoclosed after some time. If you still have a problem, make a PR with a test case or to prove that you have tried to fix the problem.