European coverage status

vkrause commented 3 months ago

Tracking issue for coverage in Europe

[ ] :albania: Albania: unknown
[ ] :andorra: Andorra: unknown
[ ] :austria: Austria: national railway included, local transport available with contract?
[x] :belgium: Belgium
[ ] :bosnia_herzegovina: Bosnia and Herzegovina: unknown
[ ] :bulgaria: Bulgaria: unknown
[ ] :croatia: Croatia: national railway included (#109), local transport unknown
[ ] :cyprus: Cyprus: Added feeds from Transitland covering (most?) of southern Cyprus #240
[ ] :czech_republic: Czechia: Prague #208, Brno, Liberec #224 , Olomuc #228
[x] :denmark: Denmark
[x] :estonia: Estonia
[ ] :finland: Finland: #116, local data also available (#126, #128)
[x] :fr: France: #305
[x] :de: Germany
[ ] :greece: Greece: Athens #238
[ ] :hungary: Hungary: #134, more local feeds to be added
[x] :iceland: Iceland: #115
[x] :ireland: Ireland
[ ] :it: Italy: more feeds to be added? #76 #77
[ ] :kosovo: Kosovo: unknown
[x] :latvia: Latvia
[ ] :liechtenstein: Liechtenstein: largely covered by the Swiss national feed
[x] :lithuania: Lithuania
[x] :luxembourg: Luxembourg
[ ] :malta: Malta: unknown
[ ] :moldova: Moldova: unknown
[ ] :monaco: Monaco: unknown
[ ] :montenegro: Montenegro: unknown
[x] :netherlands: Netherlands
[ ] :macedonia: Macedonia: unknwon
[ ] :poland: Poland: national railway included, partial local coverage?
[ ] :portugal: Portugal: Some local transport covered
[ ] :romania: Romania: unknown
[ ] :san_marino: San Marino: unknown
[ ] :serbia: Serbia: unknown
[x] :slovakia: Slovakia: #108 , local transport: Bratislava #231
[ ] :slovenia: Slovenia: unknown
[ ] :es: Spain: national railway included, partial local coverage?
[x] :sweden: Sweden
[x] :switzerland: Switzerland
[ ] :tr: Turkey: some local feeds exist
[ ] :ukraine: Ukraine: unknown
[x] :gb: United Kingdom: Great Britain done, Northern Ireland (#124)
[ ] :aland_islands: Åland: no known GTFS feed for local bus service, feed for ferry service seems available
[ ] :faroe_islands: Faroe: unknown
[ ] :svalbard_jan_mayen: Svalbard: unknown

PartTimeDataScientist commented 3 months ago

Nice overview! 😍

Would it be an idea to ask the maintainers of the feeds to add high level area IDs e.g. the stable identifiers from https://www.whosonfirst.org/?

Doing so would allow us to auto-generate a coverage map (separated by continent, country static, real-rime,...)

vkrause commented 3 months ago

Right, we still need a way to get to reliable machine-readable coverage data (see also https://github.com/public-transport/transport-apis/pull/75), in terms of area, quality and completeness. Some of this might be derivable automatically from the feed data, but at least completeness needs human assessment I think.

This ticket was more meant as a todo list for which countries we still have to search for data.

Fale commented 3 months ago

I have other ~10 feeds for Italy that I know of (probably many others are available) but they all have (different) issues, so I'm not adding them yet

jbruechert commented 3 months ago

Liechtenstein is mostly included in the Swiss data, but we are missing at least ons cable car line that has data :D

mlundblad commented 3 months ago

Maybe Åland should be counted separatly?

In GNOME Maps we currently support Finland via the OpenTripPlanner API provided by Digitransit, but it doesn't include Åland (which is autonomous, so I imagine they would supply their own feed(s).

mlundblad commented 3 months ago

And I'm assuming it is similar for the Farao islands (fo), I'm guessing it's not included in the Danish national data.

vkrause commented 3 months ago

Maybe Åland should be counted separatly?

Yep, that doesn't seem to be included elsewhere indeed. There's local bus service there by https://alandstrafiken.ax, but I can't find a GTFS feed for those. http://gtfs.lautta.net seems to provide a feed for ferries going there at least though.

vkrause commented 3 months ago

And I'm assuming it is similar for the Farao islands (fo), I'm guessing it's not included in the Danish national data.

Yep. There seems to be a local bus service, but unfortunately I can't seem to find much information about that.

jbruechert commented 3 months ago

Data for Hungarian Railways is available here: https://www.mavcsoport.hu/en/gtfs-request, but it requires sign up, including a postal address. Possibly we can ask an adjacent organization (KDE e.V?) to do this for us.

Pi-Cla commented 3 months ago

FYI, there are some places missing from this list such as: Belarus, Kosovo, Russia, Svalbard, Transnistria, and Ukraine.

It seems Kosovo and Transnistria both do have railway companies but I am unsure if those companies publish any GTFS data. Likewise Svalbard has a service called "Svalbard Bus and Taxi".

z3ntu commented 3 months ago

Austria has a bunch of data available here: https://data.mobilitaetsverbuende.at/en/data-sets But requires sign-up and some accepting some license. But with that the coverage might/should be relatively complete.

I've checked before and real-time data for Vienna with the Wiener Linien (subways etc) doesn't seem to be available in a standard format, just via their custom API. https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/522d3045-0b37-48d0-b868-57c99726b1c4#resources

mlundblad commented 2 months ago

I added Prague (PID) in #208

mlundblad commented 2 months ago

Szechia: Brno and Liberec: #224

z3ntu commented 1 month ago

I don't know if Turkey/Türkiye is in scope but Istanbul seems to have some GTFS feeds here: https://data.ibb.gov.tr/en/dataset/public-transport-gtfs-data The description says last updated 2018/2019 but on the right side right now it says

Last Updated
March 13, 2024, 2:43 PM

So I believe they're up-to-date?

There's also this other feed with a few more lines I believe? https://data.ibb.gov.tr/en/dataset/iett-gtfs-verisi

Unfortunately for the TCDD (Turkish railways) I couldn't find any feed.

jbruechert commented 1 month ago

In general everything is in scope, IMO it also makes sense to track it here

public-transport / transitous

European coverage status #114