search

public-transport / transitous

Free and open public transport routing.
https://transitous.org
179 stars 51 forks source link

Removed feeds #171

Open jbruechert opened 6 months ago

jbruechert commented 6 months ago

During the migration of the CI to a self-hosted VM, I had to remove a few feeds that were not accessible from the DFN (German University Network)

If you find another download link / a mirror, these can of course be added back. Maybe @Fale's gtfsproxy can help, although it didn't immidiately work for those feeds.

Pi-Cla commented 6 months ago

For laval I tested the link and it now permanently redirects to https://stlaval.ca/datas/opendata/GTF_STL.zip ~For transperth the feed no longer works on transitland's or my side.~ For yellowknife I have no clue... can you access this link on the university network? https://cityexplorer.yellowknife.ca/gtfs/

This link seems to contain all of the various files that are bundled into the gtfs zip file along side the zip itself. I can access it just fine on my end...

Steve-Tech commented 6 months ago

Transperth works fine for me, but Yellowknife and Laval do not, so maybe they're all doing some sort of geo ip blocking?

I could maybe host some sort of proxy for Transperth, but my uptime will probably suck.

Pi-Cla commented 6 months ago

Update: Actually I can download all three feeds on my side. But transitland seems to have problems with transperth https://www.transit.land/feeds/f-q-transperth~transalbany~transbunbury~transbusselton~transgera (Edited because Github's markdown has trouble with certain characters in the transitland url)

While Laval and Yellowknife are listed as working.

jbruechert commented 6 months ago

can you access this link on the university network? https://cityexplorer.yellowknife.ca/gtfs/

Unfortunately not, I can not even ping the domain. Likely geo / ip range blocking

wolfy1339 commented 6 months ago

Is https://stlaval.ca/datas/opendata/GTF_STL.zip working from your network? We could switch to using that URL until transitland is updated (https://github.com/transitland/transitland-atlas/pull/1064)

jbruechert commented 6 months ago

That one unfortunately has Cloudflare in front of it, so while I technically can connect to the server, I only get the HTML of the cloudflare check page. In addition to that the backend server seems to be down right now.

mexon commented 6 months ago

I have confirmed the problem accessing Transperth from Germany with at least two other networks, apart from DFN. It seems the entire site is blocked (https://www.transperth.wa.gov.au/). I've contacted Transperth using their public contact form. Perhaps there will be some feedback from there.

jbruechert commented 5 months ago

I wonder if they might be blocking the whole EU out of (unjustified) fear of the GDPR. These blocked feeds really seem to be a US problem.