search

pulp / pulp_container

Pulp Container Registry
https://docs.pulpproject.org/pulp_container/
GNU General Public License v2.0
23 stars 44 forks source link

Question about the plugin versioning #1689

Open philfry opened 3 days ago

philfry commented 3 days ago

Hi all,

I installed pulp-container using pip from pypi where 2.20.0 is the current version, see https://pypi.org/project/pulp-container/#history and https://pulpproject.org/pulp_container/changes/, even though there have been releases after 2.20.0 with lower version numbers.

Looking at this repo, 2.16.8, which was released last week, seems to be the latest version, and the tags seem out of order:

$ git tag -l -n1 | tail -n 10
2.16.6          Release 2.16.6
2.18.1          Release 2.18.1
2.19.0          Release 2.19.0
2.19.1          Release 2.19.1
2.19.2          Release 2.19.2
2.19.3          Release 2.19.3
2.20.0          Release 2.20.0
2.14.14         Release 2.14.14
2.16.7          Release 2.16.7
2.16.8          Release 2.16.8

I didn't find any hints in the documentation, maybe a specific minor version is only suitable for a specific pulpcore version? For pulpcore 3.55.1, there's no release for pulp_container yet, right? What would be the pulp_container version with pulpcore 3.55 compatibility?

lubosmj commented 3 days ago

Yes, you are right. We did not release a version compatible with pulpcore v3.55. We will strive to do the release next week (2.21?). The commit adding support for the aforementioned version landed into main two days ago: https://github.com/pulp/pulp_container/commit/a832b9fc9a06cf96fda20fc7203f06a2baa6b9c4.

Only specific minor versions are suitable for a specific pulpcore version. We do not have any compatibility matrix available at the moment. Would you like to see one in the future? For now, it is needed to look into the requirements in respective release branches (e.g., https://github.com/pulp/pulp_container/blob/2.14/requirements.txt).

philfry commented 3 days ago

Thanks for the explanation, lubosmj! A compatibility matrix (major.minor → pulpcore x.y) would be great, or at least mentioning the exclusive compatibility and giving the hint with the requirements.txt in the documentation.