search

puppetlabs / puppetserver-helm-chart

The Helm Chart for Puppet Server
Apache License 2.0
47 stars 55 forks source link

Does the Helm Chart support puppetserver 8? #210

Open cpiment opened 4 months ago

cpiment commented 4 months ago

Use Case

I would like to deploy Puppet Server 8 using this Helm chart. Is this possible? It seems that the puppet server image version is set to 7.13 by default.

Describe the Solution You Would Like

A parameter or set of parameters in the Helm chart that would allow to switch Puppet Server versions

Describe Alternatives You've Considered

Modify the chart manually

Xtigyro commented 4 months ago

@cpiment Have you tried setting the value for that line?

cpiment commented 4 months ago

HI @Xtigyro , I thought there would be some other dependent components that should be upgraded to other versions too. I will try that change and get back here with my findings. Thanks!

Xtigyro commented 4 months ago

@cpiment Most probably you'd need to set a higher value for PuppetDB too. Let me know what happens. Also - please feel free to send our way a PR. The whole chart is completely community supported.

cpiment commented 3 months ago

Hi @Xtigyro I've been able to start Puppet Server and puppet DB using this values.yaml:

puppetserver:
  tag: 8.4.0-latest
puppetdb:
  tag: 8.3.0-latest

And everything started fine. The problem is that I have tried to run Puppet Agent latest version in a Windows host and I have not been able to start it (not a problem with Puppet Server, but with the agent itself), so I have rolled it back to Puppet Server 7.

anthonysomerset commented 1 week ago

So i can confirm upgrade from 7 to puppetserver 8 works just fine when updating your values to add the puppet 8 images - with custom/imported CA and multi- CA and multi-compiler just fine

it "might" be beneficial to introduce a new config item that defaults to puppet version 7 which presets the values of those tags for 7 or 8 (or later 9) based on the config value because it would at least avoid scenarios where if a user is careless they might try to run a V8 only compatible puppetdb but only v7 server or the other way around