search

pwyf / 2018-index-indicator-definitions

1 stars 0 forks source link

Sectors #21

Open andylolz opened 7 years ago

andylolz commented 7 years ago

Description

The sectors of the activity explain whether this is, for example, a health or education project.

Proposed test

IATI 2.0x

Firstly:

For each current activity,
`sector` should be present
or `transaction/sector` should be present

Secondly:

For each current activity,
at least one
`sector[not(@vocabulary)]/@code | sector[@vocabulary="1"]/@code | transaction/sector[@vocabulary="1"]/@code | transaction/sector[not(@vocabulary)]/@code`
should be on the Sector codelist

IATI 1.0x

Firstly:

For each current activity,
`sector` should be present

Secondly:

For each current activity,
at least one
`sector[@vocabulary="DAC"]/@code | sector[not(@vocabulary)]/@code`
should be on the Sector codelist
breidertmt commented 7 years ago

TO confirm sector can be other than DAC sector with the new test?

andylolz commented 7 years ago

For the first test, a sector code using any vocabulary is fine.

The second test, though, is specifically looking for sectors using DAC 5-digit purpose codes. So an activity must include at least one sector code from the DAC 5-digit purpose code vocabulary in order to score.

francescafo commented 7 years ago

So to clarify, it will need to include a DAC code?

andylolz commented 7 years ago

Hi @francescafo,

So to clarify, it will need to include a DAC code?

For the first test, no. But for the second test, yes. The two tests are equally weighted.

So: if sectors are present on all activities, but none of them are DAC CRS 5-digit codes, then the maximum for this indicator would be 50%.

andylolz commented 7 years ago

Thanks for the comments here. These tests will remain as proposed.